Unnameable Media

The Warning: James Hughes and Indiana’s Secret War, 1862

Part 1 of 5 in Indiana’s Secret War

On June 16, 1862, James Hughes sat down in Bloomington and wrote Governor Oliver P. Morton a warning. Hughes was not an obscure informant passing along tavern gossip. He was a former Indiana congressman, a former circuit judge and Indiana University law professor, a veteran of the Mexican War, and at that moment a judge of the United States Court of Claims. He had also been a Democrat, elected to Congress as one in 1856 and appointed to the federal bench by Democratic president James Buchanan. That political biography matters, because the warning that Hughes sent to Indiana’s Republican governor crossed the partisan boundary that otherwise defined nearly everything about Indiana during the Civil War.

Hughes told Morton that a secret society existed in Indiana, that it was understood to be hostile to the payment of direct taxes supporting the war, and that it was “rapidly spreading throughout the State.” Two days later Morton read the letter before the Republican State Convention in Indianapolis; on June 19 it appeared in the Indianapolis Daily Journal. Historian Frank L. Klement later made this episode central to his argument that Republicans inflated the Knights of the Golden Circle scare for political purposes. Klement emphasized that Hughes supplied no names, lodge locations, membership lists, intercepted correspondence, or other evidence in the letter itself. Democratic newspapers at the time likewise attacked it as a partisan campaign document.

That criticism cannot simply be brushed aside. But neither does it settle the question.

The more interesting problem is what Hughes could realistically have been hearing in Bloomington in June 1862. When his letter is placed back into the geography of wartime Indiana rather than read only as a Republican convention document, it begins to look like an early signal from a much larger political crisis whose exact dimensions were still obscure. Some of the stories circulating in 1861 and 1862 were unquestionably exaggerated, partisan or fraudulent. Yet by 1863 and 1864, investigators would document oath-bound organizations, armed draft resistance, deserter-protection networks and revolutionary planning stretching across many of the same Indiana counties where rumors had circulated earlier. The historical problem is therefore not whether every Golden Circle story was true. It is whether Hughes was detecting the early formation of something that had not yet acquired the organizational structure, names and documentary trail by which historians can easily recognize it.

Before the Knights Had One Name

The phrase “Knights of the Golden Circle” already carried enormous baggage by 1862. George W. L. Bickley had promoted the organization before the war as part secret society, part filibustering scheme aimed toward Mexico and the Caribbean. During the secession crisis, Northern newspapers transformed the KGC into a convenient name for practically every suspected clandestine pro-Southern organization. Exposés purporting to reveal its signs, grips, passwords and rituals circulated throughout the Midwest. An “Authentic Exposition” of the order was actually published in Indianapolis in 1861.

Klement demonstrated that many early Golden Circle stories were unreliable. An alleged KGC operative arrested in LaPorte County in September 1861, for example, made extravagant claims about recruiting volunteers and buying revolvers for the Confederacy, but officials came to regard him as more crank than conspirator. Other sensational Golden Circle reports from Ohio and Michigan proved to contain forged letters, dubious affidavits or outright hoaxes. Indianapolis banker Calvin Fletcher even encountered men claiming KGC connections who apparently hoped to extract money from him by promising assistance for his captured son.

That background explains why Klement was so skeptical of Hughes. By early 1862, “Golden Circle” had become an accusation almost as much as the name of an identifiable organization. The Republican Indianapolis Journal was already alleging in December 1861 and March 1862 that an antiwar secret society existed in Indiana, sometimes calling it the Mutual Protective Society and suggesting that it was connected with the KGC. The Democratic Sentinel answered that these reports were partisan inventions. The information environment into which Hughes wrote was therefore badly contaminated before his letter ever reached Morton.

But contaminated intelligence is not the same thing as no intelligence.

Bloomington: Where Hughes Was Listening

Hughes had particularly deep roots in Bloomington. He had practiced law there, served on Indiana’s circuit bench and taught law at Indiana University. In October 1861 he had addressed a large Union meeting at the Bloomington courthouse, delivering what a later local history remembered as a ferociously anti-secession speech. Whatever his earlier Democratic affiliations, Hughes had positioned himself publicly and emphatically behind preservation of the Union.

Southern Indiana was also precisely the part of the state where political divisions were becoming hardest to separate from questions of loyalty, recruitment, desertion and armed resistance. Later Bloomington accounts remembered parts of Monroe County as having such pronounced Southern sympathy that communities were nicknamed “Secessia.” By 1863, letters were reportedly being sent to Monroe County soldiers encouraging desertion and promising concealment from arrest, while local histories described clandestine meetings attributed to the Knights of the Golden Circle. These later accounts cannot prove that such an apparatus existed in June 1862, but they demonstrate that the political soil around Hughes was not imaginary.

This distinction is important. Hughes did not need to have witnessed a statewide KGC command structure to hear credible reports that men were organizing locally against taxation, enlistment or federal coercion. In a nineteenth-century political world built around courthouse networks, lawyers, newspaper exchanges, party committees, militia officers and personal correspondence, a former congressman and federal judge possessed unusually good channels through which scattered information could reach him.

The June 16 letter may therefore be most useful as an intelligence document rather than as a membership report. Hughes was saying that something was spreading. He was less successful at explaining exactly what it was.

Nine Days Later, Morton Writes Washington

The strongest reason not to treat Hughes’s letter as an isolated curiosity appears only nine days later.

On June 25, Governor Morton wrote a confidential letter to Secretary of War Edwin Stanton. Morton declared that “the fact is well established” that a secret political organization existed in Indiana and said its membership was claimed to be approximately 10,000. He identified its objectives as obstructing military recruitment, generating opposition to wartime taxation, creating distrust of government and supporting newspapers hostile to the administration. Morton added that the organization was not confined to one locality but was supposedly operating throughout the state. He said reports had been reaching him “for some weeks past” from multiple locations and claimed that members were oath-bound and that meetings were guarded by armed men.

The overlap with Hughes’s warning is striking: rapid spread, resistance to taxation, obstruction of the war effort and organization extending beyond a single county. Morton may have regarded Hughes’s letter as one piece of a broader stream of information rather than the source of the entire alarm. His June 25 letter explicitly said information had been arriving from around Indiana for weeks.

Morton also had a practical reason for making the threat clear to Stanton. He wanted Washington to provide 10,000 stands of arms so loyal citizens could be organized into the Indiana Legion. His letter therefore had an institutional purpose as well as an intelligence purpose: evidence of internal danger strengthened his argument for weapons and militia organization. That gives historians another reason for caution. Morton was not a neutral observer. He was a wartime governor attempting simultaneously to understand a threat, mobilize supporters and obtain federal resources.

Yet this creates a more complicated picture than simple fabrication. Morton was making specific claims in confidential correspondence with the War Department, not merely shouting allegations from a campaign platform.

The Federal Grand Jury Problem

There was another investigation unfolding at almost exactly the same moment. A United States grand jury sitting for the May 1862 term in Indiana had taken testimony concerning alleged disloyal organizations. Its eventual presentment claimed that perhaps 15,000 Hoosiers belonged to treasonable societies, that meetings sometimes took place in secluded locations under arms, and that members were attempting to resist federal taxation and obstruct enlistment. The report even alleged connections with Confederate prisoners at Camp Morton.

Klement attacked the grand jury document even more sharply than the Hughes letter. He pointed out that its members were Republicans, that none of its forty-seven indictments actually charged participation in a secret society, and that the sweeping KGC allegations were essentially an additional statement attached to the jury’s legal work. He also noted the extraordinary tendency of investigators to interpret unwilling witnesses as evidence of the society’s secrecy.

Again, the criticism is substantial. But chronologically the grand jury is important. Testimony concerning clandestine activity was being gathered in Indiana during the same spring in which Hughes and Morton were sounding their alarms. The public controversy over the grand jury report exploded later that summer, but the investigation itself belonged to the May term. It therefore provides another indication that Hughes’s June letter emerged from an existing environment of reports and inquiries rather than appearing from nowhere.

Indianapolis: The Nerve Center

From Bloomington the story naturally moves north to Indianapolis, because the capital was where rumors became state policy.

Indianapolis contained the governor, the federal courts, major newspapers, the state arsenal and Camp Morton, where Confederate prisoners were held. Morton’s June 25 letter specifically complained about the Democratic State Sentinel, which he accused of encouraging resistance to his administration and which he said Confederate prisoners regarded favorably. The same newspaper was simultaneously attacking Republican Golden Circle allegations. Indianapolis was therefore not merely where intelligence was collected; it was where rival interpretations of the war were being manufactured and distributed.

The presence of Camp Morton added another dimension. Any serious clandestine organization capable of liberating Confederate prisoners would possess strategic significance far beyond electoral politics. By 1864 that exact possibility became central to the Sons of Liberty investigation: authorities alleged plans to seize arms and release Confederate prisoners from camps including Camp Morton. The 1864 military trials eventually revolved around those claims.

But that later plot should not simply be projected backward onto 1862. What can safely be said is that the strategic ingredients were already present: thousands of Confederate prisoners, a state arsenal, a bitterly divided electorate, recruiting difficulties and increasingly organized opposition to wartime policy.

North Toward Marion and Huntington

The most revealing test of Hughes’s warning comes when the map moves into northeastern Indiana.

Huntington was home to attorney Lambdin P. Milligan, who would eventually become one of the central defendants in the Indianapolis treason trials. In 1862, however, Milligan’s documented activity was primarily political. He delivered increasingly harsh speeches against the Lincoln administration and the war and became an influential figure among antiwar Democrats in northern Indiana. Republican opponents described him as a rebel sympathizer, and Morton’s circle collected newspaper reports about his speeches.

There is an especially useful piece of evidence from October 1862. After Democratic electoral victories, Milligan urged supporters to organize political clubs in every township, explicitly contrasting those clubs with what he called the “fabulous” Knights of the Golden Circle. That statement can be read in different ways, but at minimum it prevents us from casually labeling Milligan a proven KGC conspirator in June 1862. The documentary case for his participation in a secret antiwar organization becomes substantially stronger in 1863.

And this is where Hughes’s warning becomes more intriguing.

By the summer of 1863, a provost marshal reported an “extensive organization” operating through Wells, Huntington, Grant, Blackford and part of Madison County, whose members were allegedly armed and preparing to resist the draft. Stephen E. Towne’s later research, based heavily on provost marshal and military records, argues that investigators accumulated substantial evidence of organizations protecting deserters, interfering with conscription and acquiring weapons.

Grant County places Marion directly in that corridor. The evidence is significantly stronger for 1863 than for June 1862, so the chronology must remain intact. Yet the later pattern is difficult to ignore. Hughes had described a rapidly spreading organization before authorities possessed the later documentary clarity. A year later, federal officers were describing an armed network spanning exactly the central-to-northeastern Indiana geography that connects Indianapolis, Marion and Huntington.

That does not prove Hughes knew the details. It makes the question worth asking.

Fort Wayne and the Northern Political Network

Fort Wayne formed another important node because it was a major center of Democratic political activity and newspaper circulation. Milligan operated within a northern Indiana political world extending through Huntington and Fort Wayne, and contemporary Democratic papers carried sustained attacks on the administration. By 1863, the conflict had moved beyond newspaper columns. A Union rally in Fort Wayne on May 2 ended in violence involving Southern sympathizers; a later recollection described attacks on Union supporters and violence at the railroad station.

By 1864, Milligan would deliver one of his most incendiary speeches from a Fort Wayne hotel balcony, urging armed preparation against what he portrayed as governmental tyranny. Towne connects that speech with the revolutionary planning then occurring inside the secret order.

Once again the dates matter. Fort Wayne in June 1862 cannot simply be described as a functioning headquarters of the later Sons of Liberty. What existed first was a political communications environment: partisan newspapers, speakers, lawyers, county organizations and increasingly radical rhetoric. A clandestine structure could grow through those channels without every participant in that political environment belonging to it.

This may explain why the early reports were so difficult to evaluate. Political opposition, peace activism, secret fraternity, organized draft resistance and actual Confederate collaboration overlapped without being identical.

Klement Versus the Later Evidence

Frank Klement’s work remains indispensable because he forced historians to confront the partisan manufacturing of conspiracy stories. His 1965 article on Henry B. Carrington described much of the Indiana Golden Circle narrative as a legend expanded by Morton, Republican newspapers and military officers. In Klement’s interpretation, Hughes’s unsupported letter and the partisan grand jury report became early building blocks in that process.

Later historians have pushed back against applying that interpretation too broadly. Towne’s research into provost-marshal, military and espionage records found significant evidence that secret antiwar organizations actually operated across Indiana and neighboring states, aided deserters, resisted the draft and, in some cases, contemplated armed action. He specifically notes evidence that KGC chapters existed in Indiana, Ohio and Illinois by the early war years and traces the development into the Order of American Knights and Sons of Liberty.

David C. Keehn likewise argues that the Knights of the Golden Circle were more substantial in the secession crisis and early Civil War than the most skeptical historiography allowed. That does not mean every newspaper story, membership estimate or alleged conspiracy should be accepted. It means that the old choice between “vast conspiracy” and “Republican fantasy” is too simple.

The documentary record appears messier. There were hoaxes. There was partisan exploitation. There were exaggerated membership figures. There were also real secret organizations, armed resistance, espionage operations and later revolutionary schemes.

James Hughes stands at the beginning of that ambiguity.

What Did James Hughes Actually Know?

The surviving June 16 letter cannot answer that question. Hughes did not identify his informants. He provided no lodge roster and offered no captured correspondence. On that narrow point, Klement was correct to emphasize the evidentiary weakness of the document itself.

But the larger chronology changes its significance. Hughes wrote from a state where KGC literature and rumors had circulated since 1861; where newspapers were already arguing over secret antiwar societies by early 1862; where a federal grand jury was investigating similar allegations during the May term; and where Morton told the secretary of war nine days later that reports of an oath-bound organization had been reaching him “for some weeks past” from across Indiana. Within another year, military authorities would document armed resistance and secret organization across Huntington, Grant and neighboring counties.

That sequence does not turn Hughes’s allegation into proof. It does something more useful: it establishes the letter as an early documentary marker in Indiana’s internal Civil War.

The secret war did not suddenly materialize in Indianapolis in the summer of 1864 when investigators exposed the Sons of Liberty. Nor can it be cleanly dated to the moment someone first adopted a particular ritual or organizational name. It developed gradually from political division, secret association, resistance to recruitment, deserter protection, hostility to federal policy and fear—sometimes justified and sometimes exaggerated—that opposition could become insurrection.

Hughes wrote while those categories were still running together.

That is why June 16, 1862 deserves more attention. The importance of the letter is not that James Hughes had somehow uncovered the entire conspiracy two years early. It is that a well-connected Indiana jurist believed he was seeing an organization spread before the government possessed the machinery to describe it clearly. Two days later his warning was in Morton’s hands at the Republican convention. Nine days later Morton was telling Washington that the organization might number 10,000 and was operating throughout the state. A federal grand jury was investigating the same general phenomenon. Then, over the next two years, names that would become famous in the Indianapolis treason trials—Harrison Dodd, Lambdin Milligan and others—would emerge from the political landscape Hughes had been watching.

Seen that way, “The Warning” is the right beginning for the larger Indiana secret-war story. It starts before the spectacular arrests, before the boxes of weapons, before military spies penetrated the secret orders and before Ex parte Milligan. It starts when the evidence was fragmentary enough that historians would spend the next century arguing over whether the danger was real.

And it starts with James Hughes in Bloomington, writing the governor that something was spreading.

Leave a comment