Unnameable Media

Pinkerton and the Occult Underground

Part 9 of 9 in Private Eyes

The last letter of Paschal Beverly Randolph, the murder of a Chicago editor, and the transatlantic occult tradition that survived them both.

Chicago in 1874
Chicago in 1874, as depicted by Currier & Ives. (Alternate archival image.)

On July 20, 1875, Paschal Beverly Randolph sat down in Toledo, Ohio, to write to an old friend in Chicago. He had an idea for the city’s newspapers: an international tournament at which the world’s mystics could demonstrate their abilities before the public. He had returned from the California mining country, where he said that two men had tried to kill him, and was sufficiently disenchanted with prospecting to devote himself to his business and a book on the mysteries of the spirit world. He was even contemplating a journey to Russia. His correspondent was Judge Stevens Sanborn Jones, proprietor of the Religio-Philosophical Journal and one of the most influential spiritualist editors in the American Midwest. Randolph knew that if he could interest Jones in the tournament, he had a reasonable chance of drawing a crowd. Nine days later he was dead of a gunshot wound. When Jones printed the letter in his newspaper on August 14, alongside an account of the suicide, he gave the public a glimpse of a friendship that had extended considerably beyond their common interest in the occult. Within two years Jones would also be dead, shot from behind in his Chicago publishing house by a man reported to be related by marriage to one of Edwin Stanton’s former War Department officials. By the time of that murder, Allan Pinkerton had already written a book about his agency’s investigations among American spiritualists. It concerned a world that Randolph and Jones had spent their lives helping to create.

Randolph had been born in New York in 1825, the son of a Black mother and a father he associated, with uncertain particulars, with the Randolph family of Virginia. He spent part of his youth at sea, traveled abroad and earned his living in the 1850s as a lecturer and trance medium. His reputation subsequently came to rest on a highly personal system of Rosicrucian philosophy in which the development of the will, the use of crystals and mirrors, and the spiritual possibilities of affection and sexual love occupied a central place. His claims to have received instruction from occult masters abroad are harder to substantiate than his publishing career, but the political work he undertook during the Civil War is considerably better documented. He helped recruit Black soldiers and participated in the education of freed people in Louisiana. Jones remembered receiving his reports from the New Orleans schools. When Randolph later traveled north as a member of a delegation of southern Union loyalists, some of the white delegates, according to Jones, tried to prevent him from speaking on behalf of the people he represented. Randolph left the party and reached Chicago ahead of his colleagues, where he turned to the man who had been publishing his correspondence from the South.

Paschal Beverly Randolph, photographed by Rodney Poole in Nashville in 1874, one year before his death.
Paschal Beverly Randolph, photographed by Rodney Poole in Nashville in 1874, one year before his death. Source

Jones took the matter directly to the Tremont House. Governor Richard J. Oglesby and General John A. Logan were preparing to travel with a reception party to Michigan City, Indiana, where they would meet the delegation on its way into Chicago. When Oglesby learned what had happened, Jones recalled, the governor insisted that Randolph accompany them. The next day, at Lake Park, Randolph was given a platform of his own; his audience, according to the editor, was larger than the crowds gathered around the other speakers’ stands. Oglesby was a former Union general, and Logan would become commander-in-chief of the Grand Army of the Republic. The intervention concerned Randolph’s right to speak for freed people, and nothing in Jones’s account suggests that either man shared his occult convictions. Yet the episode is worth remembering when reading Randolph’s last letter. Jones was a friend with access to the political leadership of Illinois, a former judge and railroad promoter who had established his spiritualist journal in the spring of 1865. Randolph’s appeal to him for a worldwide exhibition of mysticism came after an earlier occasion on which the editor had secured him a platform in Chicago through the personal cooperation of the governor.

Their correspondence in July 1875 was preoccupied with a scandal that had been consuming American newspapers for much of the preceding year. Henry Ward Beecher, the celebrated Brooklyn minister and abolitionist, had been accused of adultery with Elizabeth Tilton, the wife of a former friend. The trial ended with a divided jury that July. Randolph was delighted with the position Jones had taken in Beecher’s defense, particularly with the editor’s efforts to separate the freedom to discuss intimate moral questions from the more scandalous reputation of free love. Randolph knew firsthand how easily the two could be conflated. His writings on sexual mysticism had placed him at odds with conventional religious opinion and with the rapidly expanding machinery of obscenity enforcement. He also believed himself to have made enemies abroad and at home. In his letter he recounted four occasions on which he said his life had been endangered: Spain in 1860, Turkey in 1863, Perrysburg in 1874 and Bishop Creek in California. Concerning the last of these, he offered names. Among the people he credited with helping him were Frank Hutchinson, Hutchinson’s wife and brother, John E. Jones and a Mr. Burcham of Round Valley. Their appearance in the letter gives the historian something unusually concrete to pursue in a body of writing so often concerned with anonymous masters and private revelations.

RELIGIO-PHILOSOPHICAL JOURNAL · AUGUST 14, 1875 · P. 172

His Very Last Letter

“Friend Jones, why don’t you get up a World’s Mystic Tournament in Chicago”

TRANSCRIBED EXCERPT FROM THE ORIGINAL PUBLICATIONRead the original scanned document ↗

Whatever Randolph’s actual circumstances in California, the writer who returned to Ohio sounded full of plans. He was working on Beyond the Spheres, investigating clairvoyance and considering an invitation or challenge involving French and Russian scholars. His reference to having survived a dangerous March 29 acquired an entirely different meaning when Jones published the letter after his death on July 29. The editor wondered about the correspondence between the dates, but he also remembered receiving earlier letters in which Randolph had contemplated taking his life. In Jones’s judgment the racial humiliation to which his friend had repeatedly been subjected contributed to his despair. Later Rosicrucian traditions circulated alternative accounts of the death, including the assertion that Randolph had been murdered. His own allegations about earlier threats give ample reason to investigate the named witnesses in California, although neither they nor the coincidence of dates establish a homicide in Toledo. The contemporary report of suicide, particularly in light of Jones’s testimony about their earlier correspondence, remains an accounting of Randolph’s death that any alternative explanation must contend with. When the editor printed his friend’s final words for the spiritualists of Chicago, he could scarcely have anticipated that the explanation of his own death would soon become another dispute in the pages of the same newspaper.

Title page of an edition of Eulis, Randolph’s work on the occult philosophy of love and sexuality.
Title page of an edition of Eulis, Randolph’s work on the occult philosophy of love and sexuality. Source

In the nineteenth century a spiritualist editor could accumulate a remarkable knowledge of the private lives of people scattered across the country. A medium advertising a lecture in Chicago might have come from New York or Detroit and be planning to continue by rail to St. Louis; a letter to the editor could bring news of a successful appearance, a disputed manifestation or a falling-out with a patron long before the lecturer arrived at the next station. The publisher heard from those who wished to recommend practitioners and from families convinced that their affairs were being interfered with by strangers. Jones had established his newspaper in a city whose railroads, express offices and commercial mail afforded an increasingly reliable means of conducting this business. Following the Great Fire of 1871, the commercial district in which his publishing house stood was rebuilt with the offices and warehouses of a resurgent city. The paper’s national circulation exposed its proprietor to questions of religious belief, intimate conduct and money that could ordinarily have remained within the confines of a private household. By March 1877 the editor himself had become the subject of just such a dispute, conducted at close quarters with a couple who had formerly lived in rooms in his building.

On March 15, William C. Pike walked into the Harrison Street police station carrying a revolver and told the policeman on duty that he had killed a man. The officer initially thought he was the victim of a joke, until Pike produced the weapon with two recently discharged chambers and explained, with the professional assurance of a lecturer on phrenology, that he knew where to shoot. Captain Buckley sent Officer Kirch to 127 Fourth Avenue, where the employees were still attending to the ordinary business of a printing establishment, apparently unaware that a shooting had occurred on the premises. Jones’s private office was at the rear, beyond a narrow passage from the business office. Its door had a self-locking latch. When the police gained access to the room they found the editor fatally wounded on the floor. A report published in the Boston Spiritual Scientist on March 22 took note of the position of his chair and the absence of signs of a struggle. The comparison that occurred to the reporter had nothing to do with Randolph, who had been dead for almost twenty months, or the longstanding controversies about Rosicrucianism. It was with the assassination at Ford’s Theatre: Jones, the article observed, had been shot from behind as Lincoln had been twelve years earlier.

SPIRITUAL SCIENTIST · MARCH 22, 1877 · P. 31

The Murder of S. S. Jones

“He had been shot, like Lincoln, from behind.”

TRANSCRIBED EXCERPT FROM THE ORIGINAL PUBLICATIONRead the original scanned document ↗

The police investigation uncovered a dispute involving Pike’s wife, Genevieve, and the couple’s former tenancy in the publishing house. They had left after difficulties with other occupants, owing back rent on a twenty-eight-dollar note of which four dollars had been paid. Shortly before his murder Jones had asked one of his clerks to retrieve the note. It was missing when his body was examined and was reportedly recovered from Pike. The latter alleged that Jones had seduced his wife and gave the police what he claimed to be her written confession. Jones’s friends denied the charge and suspected that the couple had tried to extort money from him. Their colleagues in the spiritualist press naturally had an interest in protecting the editor’s reputation, and their interpretation of Genevieve’s conduct cannot be taken as an impartial finding. The coroner’s jury recommended that she be held as an accessory pending grand jury action. When Pike himself came to trial in August 1877, he was acquitted on grounds of insanity and committed. Much of the public attention was consequently diverted to the affair that Pike had alleged, the state of his mind and the degree to which his wife had been implicated. Down near the end of the contemporary account appeared a detail of a different order: the traveling lecturer, whose credentials as a practitioner of phrenology and psychology were disputed, was reportedly the brother-in-law of P. H. Watson, the former president of the Erie Railroad.

Peter Hitchcock Watson had been Edwin M. Stanton’s colleague in patent law before joining the War Department as assistant secretary in 1862. His responsibilities included supervision of Lafayette C. Baker’s detective organization, which investigated suspected disloyalty, fraud and the traffic in supplies during the Civil War. He knew the wartime administration from the inside and subsequently made a successful return to corporate life, involving himself in the coal industry and serving as president of the Erie from 1872 to 1875. The contemporary newspaper’s identification of Watson as Pike’s brother-in-law is an intriguing clue whose genealogical particulars still require confirmation. Even if established, it would tell us nothing by itself about Watson’s knowledge of the killing. Its value lies elsewhere. Jones’s association with Randolph had already taken him into the company of the men governing Illinois at the end of the Civil War; the account of his death has now led, through a purported family relationship of his killer, to the former head of one of the great eastern railroads and the official who had overseen part of Stanton’s intelligence apparatus. Both connections appear in the newspapers of the period. Neither was supplied by the occult organizations that would later lay claim to Randolph’s teachings.

Allan Pinkerton and men of George B. McClellan’s intelligence service at Cumberland Landing, Virginia, May 1862. Pinkerton’s operation was distinct from Baker’s War Department detectives. National Archives.
Allan Pinkerton and men of George B. McClellan’s intelligence service at Cumberland Landing, Virginia, May 1862. Pinkerton’s operation was distinct from Baker’s War Department detectives. National Archives. Source

Two months before the murder, in January 1877, Allan Pinkerton had dated the preface to The Spiritualists and the Detectives in Chicago. His book, copyrighted in 1876, concerned an investigation in which his operatives entered a religious community on behalf of a wealthy client whose private affairs had become the subject of a legal threat. Pinkerton explained that he had altered names and moved the principal setting several hundred miles away from the actual location; he represented the underlying events as drawn from the agency’s records. The preface is crucial because it places the preparation of the book before Jones’s murder. There can be no question of its having been written in response to the shooting, and the concealed identities make it impossible, without further case records, to establish that it involved Jones or any of the other people in this history. What the book does offer is a contemporary account of the methods a private intelligence organization claimed to have employed inside a community of spiritualists. Pinkerton had made his reputation investigating railroads and had directed intelligence work for George B. McClellan during the Civil War. The agency remained distinct from the federal detectives of Baker and Watson. Its postwar clientele, however, belonged to much the same commercial world in which a publisher like Jones conducted his business. A successful detective had good reason to understand how its less conventional religious associations worked.Open the archival image ↗The Spiritualists and the Detectives, Allan Pinkerton. The digitized edition is from 1889; its preface was written in January 1877. Source

Pinkerton’s client appears under the name Louis Lyon, and the woman threatening legal proceedings against him is called Mrs. Winslow. To ascertain the nature of her activities, he sent operatives designated Bristol and Fox into her neighborhood with carefully differentiated social roles. Fox cultivated a respectable appearance. Bristol professed a convivial interest in spiritualism, which made it possible for him to join the women boarding near the spiritualist meeting hall and hear their conversations after the meetings. He could listen to stories about the lecturers, their associates and the occurrences of the evening without having to account for a detective’s curiosity. Through such conversations Pinkerton’s men claimed to learn a great deal about the private affairs of people whose names might never have appeared in a public proceeding. The method would have been familiar to an operative infiltrating the workforce of a railroad, but in this instance it was the religious gathering rather than a company depot that brought together the people with useful information. Another of the book’s episodes concerns Evalena Gray, a New York medium who permitted spectators to bind her to a chair in preparation for a manifestation. Pinkerton’s account dwells on the precautions taken to satisfy the audience that she was properly restrained, and on the opportunities for deception once the room was darkened. People who attended séances had reason to pay close attention to the apparition they expected to see; a detective whose suspicions lay elsewhere would be interested in everything happening around it.

Allan Pinkerton, photographed in the nineteenth century. Library of Congress.
Allan Pinkerton, photographed in the nineteenth century. Library of Congress. Source

Much of Pinkerton’s account had a counterpart in the spiritualist newspapers. On the very page of the Religio-Philosophical Journal that carried Randolph’s final letter, the next article dealt with the controversial materializations of Katie King, one of the best-known supposed spirits of the 1870s. Jones regularly published disputes over the authenticity of such phenomena and knew the difficulty of preventing a medium who had been exposed in one city from acquiring testimonials in another. He and Pinkerton approached the problem from very different convictions, but the community each described was held together in part by confidential information, friendships and financial transactions. It also possessed a press capable of transmitting accusations from one end of the country to the other. Those qualities made it of interest to publishers, wealthy patrons, religious entrepreneurs and the men who sold private investigations. Pinkerton’s stories were also advertisements for his agency, and it would be a mistake to read their reconstructed dialogue and carefully concealed identities as verbatim police records. Taken alongside the reporting on Jones’s death, they do nevertheless reveal an aspect of Reconstruction-era Chicago that tends to disappear when religious history and the history of private policing are written in isolation. Both professions had acquired national reach in the same railroad city, and at least some of their business concerned the same intimate affairs.

There was another, more private variety of esotericism in Chicago during the years of Jones’s editorship. On June 17, 1867, adherents of the Egyptian Rite of Memphis assembled in Apollo Commandery Hall to organize an American jurisdiction. Calvin C. Burt and his associates disputed the right of the Grand Orient of France to reduce the number of degrees in the rite; their own organization preserved a system extending to the ninety-sixth degree and held subsequent conventions in Chicago, Jackson and Detroit. The records of Burt’s organization, preserved in part at the Scottish Rite Masonic Museum and Library, establish that a French-derived tradition of Egyptian Masonry was operating in the Great Lakes region during Randolph’s lifetime. The spiritualist newspaper by contrast addressed a much wider public, and the presence of both organizations in the city is insufficient to identify their respective members with one another. Still, the coexistence of a thriving occult press and societies conferring elaborate private degrees would become a recurring feature of Chicago’s religious life. A student who purchased books from Jones’s successors in the closing decades of the century could encounter teachings with an international pedigree without necessarily having to travel outside the state of Illinois.

After the murder, Jones’s daughter Mary and her husband, the Union veteran Colonel John Curtis Bundy, kept the newspaper alive. Bundy assumed editorial control and took ownership of the business in 1879. A decade later the publishing house issued The Light of Egypt, associated with the English occultist Thomas Henry Burgoyne and the circle of the Hermetic Brotherhood of Luxor. Advertisements in the autumn issues of the journal offered Chicago’s readers a work concerned with the soul, reincarnation and the mysteries of Egypt and Chaldea. The editor who had published Randolph’s obituary in 1875 could not have known that his own firm would be selling a book in 1889 whose intellectual history ran back in considerable part to Randolph himself. The resemblance went deeper than the customary invocation of Egypt. Documents recovered from the Hermetic Brotherhood demonstrate the incorporation of Randolph’s writings and practical occult doctrines into its private courses of instruction. Peter Davidson, a Scottish occultist who later settled in Georgia, and Burgoyne, who wrote under a name other than his own, were among the organization’s principal figures. Through the correspondence network they cultivated in the 1880s, the work of an American Rosicrucian who had failed to establish a lasting public reputation during his lifetime became available to a new generation of European initiates.

RELIGIO-PHILOSOPHICAL JOURNAL · SEPTEMBER 1889

The Light of Egypt

Published by the Religio-Philosophical Publishing House, Chicago.

TRANSCRIBED EXCERPT FROM THE ORIGINAL PUBLICATIONRead the original scanned document ↗

Among the Europeans who acquired occult instruction through Davidson was Gérard Encausse, the French physician better known as Papus. The surviving literature of the Hermetic Brotherhood, assembled and studied by Joscelyn Godwin, Christian Chanel and John Patrick Deveney, makes this transmission more accessible than the claims of immemorial antiquity that the orders themselves cultivated. Papus acknowledged Davidson as a teacher in practical occultism and subsequently became one of the chief organizers of the French revival, working across Martinism, Rosicrucianism, Gnostic Christianity and Egyptian Masonry. In the Parisian milieu that developed around him, the question of individual initiation could be accompanied by a much larger proposition about the organization of society. Papus admired Alexandre Saint-Yves d’Alveydre, whose conception of Synarchy placed spiritual, intellectual and economic authorities within an ordered system of government. The French occult revival had thus acquired a political vocabulary of its own, distinct from the circumstances of American Reconstruction in which Randolph had developed his public career. The traditions were brought into contact through the international circulation of private teachings, and the books that emerged from that circulation allowed subsequent readers to encounter an amalgam of American and European ideas without necessarily recognizing its disparate origins.

Gérard Encausse, known as Papus, whose French Martinist circle drew upon the practical occult tradition of the Hermetic Brotherhood of Luxor.
Gérard Encausse, known as Papus, whose French Martinist circle drew upon the practical occult tradition of the Hermetic Brotherhood of Luxor. Source

Chicago’s publishers were already accustomed to bringing such material to an American audience. The Chicago World’s Fair of 1893, held four years after the publication of The Light of Egypt, gave psychical researchers occasion to present their work alongside a remarkable variety of religious, scientific and political movements. Bundy had helped foster the intellectual community from which the psychical science congress emerged, although he died in 1892 and did not live to attend it. One of the city’s most prominent patrons of psychical research was Lyman J. Gage, president of the First National Bank of Chicago and later secretary of the United States Treasury. Seven years before the fair, Gage’s name had surfaced in a quite different Chicago proceeding: the trial following the Haymarket bombing. Pinkerton operative Andrew C. Johnson acknowledged under questioning in July 1886 that Gage’s name appeared on intelligence reports, although Johnson maintained that he reported directly to the agency. Albert Parsons, one of the defendants, subsequently alleged that Gage had employed Johnson on behalf of the Citizens’ Association. The precise commercial relationship requires examination of the agency and association records, but the trial testimony gives the investigation of Chicago’s occult community a second contemporary point of contact with the private detective industry. Gage went on to support psychical research and later became associated with the Theosophical community at Point Loma. His interests were part of the public life of a man who occupied positions of considerable authority in American finance.

Lyman J. Gage in a publication of the World’s Congress Auxiliary, 1894. This portrait comes from the era of Chicago’s psychical science congress.
Lyman J. Gage in a publication of the World’s Congress Auxiliary, 1894. This portrait comes from the era of Chicago’s psychical science congress. Source

The international contacts cultivated by the French occultists became more tangible in Chicago soon afterward. Édouard Blitz, a delegate of Papus’s Martinist movement in America, visited the city in 1896. By 1901 the Chicago journal Star of the Magi was publishing material by Papus and serving as an organ of American Martinism. Here the geographical relationship had come full circle: a French occultist whose practical instruction owed something to an American author’s work was now furnishing instruction to the readers of an American publication. A new generation of students could join an initiatory organization through the auspices of a printed periodical, just as Randolph’s readers had once discovered his ideas through Jones’s newspaper. The organizations did not necessarily share a continuous administration, and the succession of rival orders makes that exceedingly difficult to presume. The publishing record, by contrast, leaves a trail that can be followed from one city to another, and makes it possible to recognize intellectual descent even where no continuous membership rolls survive. By the twentieth century the mail-order occult society had become a familiar enough institution to occupy a regular place in Chicago’s magazine business.

The December 1900 cover of Chicago’s Star of the Magi. In 1901 the journal became an organ of the American Martinist movement and carried Papus’s writings. IAPSOP.
The December 1900 cover of Chicago’s Star of the Magi. In 1901 the journal became an organ of the American Martinist movement and carried Papus’s writings. IAPSOP. Source

In January 1931, during the year of Al Capone’s federal tax-evasion conviction, a reader of Chicago’s Occult Digest could find an advertisement for a group called the Choronzon Club. Its secretary, Cecil Frederick Russell, had been associated with Aleister Crowley; the advertisement gave the prospective member a Chicago post-office box through which to make contact. Russell’s magical fraternity participated in the disputed and frequently reorganized world of societies descended from, or claiming affinities with, the Ordo Templi Orientis. Retrospective accounts of the group mention a Chicago branch that continued independently of Russell and was ultimately associated with Michael Paul Bertiaux, whose own occult organizations would become active in the city decades later. That succession remains less securely documented than the advertisement itself. What is clear is that during the period in which Chicago acquired its international reputation for organized crime, the city also accommodated an extensive commercial market for esoteric literature, secret societies and instruction by correspondence. Russell’s advertisement demonstrates the presence of a specific organization in Prohibition-era Chicago, although it offers no evidence that Capone or any other figure in the criminal underworld belonged to it. Its real historical value is that it supplies a name and address contemporaneous with the activities ascribed to the club by its later successors.

December 1925 cover of Chicago’s Occult Digest, whose later January 1931 issue advertised the Choronzon Club. IAPSOP.
December 1925 cover of Chicago’s Occult Digest, whose later January 1931 issue advertised the Choronzon Club. IAPSOP. Source

That year was equally consequential for Randolph’s reputation in France. Maria de Naglowska, a Russian-born writer who had settled in Paris, published a French work titled Magia Sexualis under Randolph’s name. The differences between her text and his surviving English writings make it difficult to disentangle his original doctrines from Naglowska’s own interpretation. In the religious movement she subsequently organized, the Brotherhood of the Golden Arrow, sexual initiation and Luciferian symbolism acquired a prominence that would have surprised many readers of the American’s nineteenth-century work. Randolph’s writings had now become a source of inspiration for a circle associated with French Satanism, although that later appropriation cannot be used to retrospectively classify Randolph himself as a Satanist. Consider the distance the material had traveled in the intervening fifty-six years. In 1875 its author was trying to persuade a Chicago editor to arrange an international gathering at which mystics could present themselves to the press. In 1931 an occult writer in Paris was introducing his name to readers who could hardly have known about that letter, while a Chicago magazine was advertising a magical society from which later local practitioners would claim an inheritance. The American and French movements had continued to develop in relation to one another long after the original participants were dead.

Bruce-Roberts’s pictorial map of gangland Chicago, published in 1931, the year of the Choronzon Club advertisement. The map is urban context, not evidence of a relationship between the club and criminal organizations.
Bruce-Roberts’s pictorial map of gangland Chicago, published in 1931, the year of the Choronzon Club advertisement. The map is urban context, not evidence of a relationship between the club and criminal organizations. Source

Papus also had a successor considerably closer to home. His son Philippe Encausse was born in 1906 and was ten years old at his father’s death in 1916. Like his father he trained as a physician, pursuing a professional career that also took him into the French administration of youth and sports and the Olympic movement. Following the Second World War he helped revive the Martinist Order, serving as its grand master from 1960 to 1979. An American’s account of an encounter with him many years later is the reason his name enters the history of Chicago’s twentieth-century occult underground. Before accepting that account, it is worth establishing the ordinary facts of Encausse’s movements through the manuscripts and correspondence held by the municipal library in Lyon. His public appointments and leadership of an international religious organization present better prospects for the recovery of a travel record than the obscure activities of many of the period’s other occult teachers. If he did confer the degree subsequently attributed to him, the alleged encounter would belong to the later years of his life, not the years of Capone’s ascendancy. The earlier Chicago connection lies with the organizations and publications already operating there when he was a young man.

William Schnoebelen, who became an evangelical Christian author after his involvement in various occult religions, described that encounter on the Almost False podcast in March 2025. He claimed that Papus’s son had come from Paris to confer the ninety-seventh degree upon him, and recalled a separate initiation into a Satanic organization in the suburbs of Chicago. The accounts are useful for what they suggest about the identities and activities of his former associates, but not every claim about his rank, initiators or supernatural experiences has independent corroboration. One of the people with whom he associated in the late 1970s, Michael Paul Bertiaux, can be followed through organizational documents. Bertiaux had traveled to Haiti in 1963 and later maintained a complex relationship among the Gnostic Church, Egyptian Masonry, the Ordo Templi Orientis Antiqua, the Monastery of the Seven Rays and an order known as La Couleuvre Noire. He attributed his instruction to a Franco-Haitian succession going back through the Jean-Maine family to the Parisian occult revival. The earlier parts of that genealogy have been disputed, but printed material circulating around 1978 names Chicago lodges, describes their meetings and stipulates physical attendance for certain initiations. It also identifies Bertiaux as the leader of his branch of Memphis-Misraïm. More than a century after Burt’s convention in Chicago, Egyptian degrees and a claimed French ancestry were once again part of the city’s esoteric life. Whether the two American jurisdictions shared any direct institutional descent has yet to be demonstrated.

Schnoebelen’s expressly Satanic associations can be pursued through an altogether different set of records. In his 1993 autobiography he described a mentor in the Chicago suburbs; a former associate subsequently identified him as David D. DePaul of Wheaton. DePaul’s name occurs in a federal court decision from Indiana, Childs v. Duckworth, in 1981. An incarcerated man seeking recognition of Satanic religious services had submitted correspondence attributed to DePaul, associated with such titles as the Church of Universal Brotherhood and the Church of the All-Seeing Eye. The court questioned aspects of the prisoner’s account and remarked upon the different names used by the organizations. The document nonetheless places DePaul and this nomenclature in a contemporary legal proceeding well before the former occultist’s autobiographical accounts were published. In 1994 the historian of religion Massimo Introvigne corresponded with Bertiaux, who said that he had encouraged DePaul to attempt contact with the supposed spirit of Diana Vaughan. From those activities, according to Bertiaux, DePaul developed a society based on the Palladium, the alleged secret order of Luciferian Freemasonry that French anti-Masonic literature had made infamous nearly a century earlier.

Le Frondeur, April 25, 1897, publicizing Léo Taxil’s exposure of the Palladium hoax. The later Chicago Palladium drew on the debunked legend.
Le Frondeur, April 25, 1897, publicizing Léo Taxil’s exposure of the Palladium hoax. The later Chicago Palladium drew on the debunked legend. Source

Diana Vaughan presents a particularly curious case of the movement of occult mythology across the Atlantic. She had been promoted during the sensational campaign waged by Léo Taxil against Freemasonry in the 1890s, in which he claimed to expose an international Satanic conspiracy with a hidden ritual organization at its center. In April 1897 Taxil publicly confessed that the affair was a hoax; among those who had challenged his allegations was Papus. However fictitious Vaughan’s biography had been, her name was still sufficiently evocative for an American occultist of the 1970s to attempt to enlist her as a spiritual intermediary. If Bertiaux’s account is accurate, a fraudulent representation of an occult society had ultimately provided the foundation for a modern society of the same name. Randolph’s own posthumous reputation had undergone a related transformation when his writings appeared in the Paris of Naglowska. The two histories are connected through a culture of publishing and creative adaptation, though they began with quite different material: in one case the work of a real nineteenth-century American author, in the other a fictional French exposé. By the time of DePaul’s association with Schnoebelen, French occult mythology, Egyptian degrees, Gnostic ecclesiastical claims and American traditions of practical magic had all become available to a relatively small circle of practitioners in metropolitan Chicago.

There is a temptation, having followed those connections backward through the twentieth century, to explain the deaths of Randolph and Jones in terms of the elaborate underground that emerged afterward. The evidence from 1875 and 1877 suggests a more difficult historical task. Jones’s account of his friend’s suicide must be compared with Randolph’s own allegations about earlier threats and any surviving records concerning the shooting in Toledo. The murder at Fourth Avenue has a named perpetrator, a dispute over money and an alleged affair, an insanity verdict and a reported family connection to the former supervisor of the War Department’s detectives. It is the latter connection that invites a closer examination of the Pike and Watson families, just as Pinkerton’s decision to disguise the particulars of his spiritualist case invites an examination of his agency’s original records. The existence of a substantial French-derived Masonic organization in 1867, the evidence from the Haymarket trial and the subsequent international history of Chicago’s publishers all establish a rich setting for that research. None provides a missing police record or establishes coordination between the two deaths. Much of the fascination of this history comes from the ability to bring its different domains into view through records created while the people involved were still alive, from the account of a governor’s intervention on Randolph’s behalf to the trial testimony concerning a banker who supported psychical science.

The last letter from Toledo survives because Jones printed it. Pinkerton, writing a book in the same city, preserved the outline of an investigation into the spiritualist world while deliberately concealing some of the particulars a historian would most like to know. When Jones’s successors published The Light of Egypt, the firm returned to the very sort of literary undertaking that Randolph had pursued, this time drawing on the work of an international brotherhood that had adopted his teachings. Half a century after his death a reader could still encounter his name in Paris, and the intellectual descendants of Papus were circulating their own widely embellished histories of initiation. The ambitious tournament Randolph had proposed would have brought the mystics of the world to Chicago and given the newspapers an opportunity to judge their performances. There is no record here of the tournament ever taking place. Instead, the city’s publishers brought a succession of those mystics to the public in books and periodicals, carrying their ideas across borders and preserving the otherwise inaccessible record of their disputes. What remains of the occult underground today owes more to their presses than to the secrecy of their initiations.

Leave a comment