
Celtic legends, Templar traditions, Bonapartism and the secret fraternities of the American frontier

The men on horseback in the newspaper look as though they have ridden out of an American film. Their faces disappear under tall white hoods, and their robes extend almost to the ground. The headline above the illustration is French. In enormous blue letters it asks, Qu’est-ce que la synarchie? What is synarchy?
The date is August 10, 1945. Marshal Philippe Pétain is on trial for treason, France is emerging from occupation, and Simone Badia, writing for the Resistance-associated newspaper Femmes françaises, wants to know whether the private interests accused of governing Vichy have survived the regime. She names Banque Worms, the de Wendel industrial family, the former interior minister Pierre Pucheu and the engineer Jean Coutrot. She asks whether La Cagoule, the organization responsible for political murders and an attempted conspiracy against the Republic in the 1930s, was a subsidiary of synarchy. Her readers are offered the little hooded figures as an explanation of how secret government looks.
Twenty-eight years earlier, an American film had made a considerably more audacious claim about that same costume. A Mormon Maid, released in 1917, dressed the Mormon Danites in robes resembling those of the Ku Klux Klan and announced that the American Klan had inherited its costume from them. The historical organization had existed in Missouri in 1838, a generation before the Klan appeared in Tennessee. Here was a ready-made history of the hood, projected across two continents and almost a century of political upheaval.

The filmmakers had invented the genealogy. There is no contemporary evidence that the Missouri Danites wore the uniform depicted on screen. Yet the possibility that the Klan inherited elements of an older European repertoire deserves a much more serious investigation than the film supplied. The French Revolution, the flight of Napoleonic officers to America, the creation of Mormon political institutions and the struggles over slavery all produced secret associations whose members claimed an authority beyond the public institutions of their day. At the same time, religious writers were arguing that the original title to the American continent could be located in the genealogies of the Bible. If we want to understand what was lost when the story of these fraternities became the story of men in white sheets, we must recover the political world that preceded them.
The French connection begins before the French Revolution, and even before the existence of France and Britain as the modern nation-states that would eventually compete for North America. Medieval Brittany, Normandy, Scotland, Ireland and England belonged to a political and literary world whose inhabitants crossed the Channel and the Irish Sea in pursuit of marriages, military service, land and dynastic claims. The crusading knight, the dispossessed king and the warrior bound by a sacred vow became recognizable characters throughout that world. By the nineteenth century those characters supplied a language in which American fraternities could describe themselves.
The story of King Arthur offers an unusually clear example of that exchange. Arthur belongs to the legendary history of Britain, but the familiar image of his knights owes an enormous debt to France. The Norman poet Wace introduced the Round Table into his twelfth-century adaptation of Geoffrey of Monmouth. Chrétien de Troyes developed the French Arthurian romance, giving literary form to the adventures of Lancelot and the quest associated with the Grail. Later French prose romances elaborated the sacred object into a Christian mystery, and Thomas Malory brought much of that French literary inheritance back into English in the fifteenth century. The famous brotherhood imagined as defending Britain had been constructed across linguistic and political frontiers.

Alongside those romances stood actual religious military orders. The Knights Templar emerged in the crusading world in the early twelfth century and developed extensive estates and financial interests in Europe. Philip IV of France ordered the arrests of Templars in his kingdom in 1307; Clement V suppressed the order in 1312. In later centuries the fate of the Temple became a subject of speculation about the survival of secret authority after the destruction of its visible institutions. The romance of that survival would prove especially durable in Scotland.
In 1295, Scotland and France established the military and diplomatic relationship remembered as the Auld Alliance. Scottish soldiers subsequently fought alongside the French during the Hundred Years’ War. At the time of Joan of Arc, Scottish contingents were serving the Valois cause against England; Scots also became associated with the royal bodyguard in France. The alliance was a real institution, enduring in varying forms until the political realignments of 1560. The idea of a fraternity whose members owed service to a foreign monarch was therefore grounded in familiar historical experience. It did not require a surviving medieval Templar order to make it intelligible.
Within this Franco-Scottish world emerged the later legends surrounding the St Clairs, or Sinclairs, of Rosslyn. Henry Sinclair, who became Earl of Orkney in 1379, is the historical figure retrospectively identified with an alleged expedition to North America around 1398. The story depends upon a contested identification of the prince called Zichmni in the Zeno narrative, published in Venice in 1558. That publication appeared more than a century and a half after the supposed expedition and included islands whose existence later cartographers accepted in error. The Library of Congress notes the fictitious island of Frisland among them.

Rosslyn Chapel itself was founded in 1446 by Henry’s grandson William St Clair. Its carved stonework has attracted interpretations involving the Grail, Freemasonry, the Temple and alleged American plants. The building is genuine; the proposed pre-Columbian voyage and Templar custodianship of relics are not established by the surviving record. The historical importance of these legends lies partly in their later reception. They offered successive generations a story in which an ancient brotherhood survived persecution, transmitted its knowledge through a family and crossed the Atlantic before the ordinary political history of America had begun.

Irish legendary history developed its own conception of ancient migration. The medieval Lebor Gabála Érenn, or Book of the Taking of Ireland, placed the ancestors of the Gaels within a universal history beginning with the biblical Flood. Its genealogy passed through Japheth, Magog and the ancestors of the Gaels, incorporating traditions involving Egypt, Scythia and Spain. The descendants of Míl Espáine eventually reached Ireland from Iberia. These traditions are not evidence for the actual population history of Ireland, but they reveal a medieval intellectual practice that would later reappear in American accounts of the Lost Tribes: the insertion of a nation’s history into a scriptural chronology, with migrations, inheritance and the possession of territory interpreted in biblical terms.
In 1588 the long-standing associations between Ireland and Spain took on a less legendary character. The Spanish Armada, having failed to secure its objective against England, attempted to return to Spain around Scotland and Ireland. Storms drove a number of its vessels ashore along the western and northern coasts of Ireland. Survivors found themselves in territory contested by the English Crown and local Gaelic lords. Some were killed, others robbed or arrested, and others sheltered by communities whose political and religious sympathies lay with Spain.

Captain Francisco de Cuéllar left an eyewitness account of his survival from the wreck of La Lavia at Streedagh. He traveled through Sligo and Leitrim, reaching the territory of Brian O’Rourke and subsequently taking refuge with MacClancy at Rosclogher Castle on Lough Melvin. His account describes not merely hospitality, but a military alliance in miniature. When English troops approached, Cuéllar and a company of Spanish survivors helped defend MacClancy’s island stronghold. They remained there until the besieging forces withdrew in severe winter weather. MacClancy offered Cuéllar marriage to his sister, but the captain sought passage to Scotland and eventually escaped to the Continent.
Cuéllar’s letter, written in 1589, is a rare opportunity to observe the politics of the Gaelic world from the perspective of a foreign soldier. It demonstrates how religious solidarity, the authority of a local clan and hostility to English expansion could bring together men who belonged to different kingdoms. It also helps explain why Scotland and Ireland appear together in so many subsequent histories of dynastic exile. The often repeated claim that Armada survivors supplied the ancestry of a distinct population of dark-haired Irish people goes much further than the evidence permits. The military and religious alliances, however, require no such genealogical assumption.
After the defeat of the Jacobite cause in Ireland, the Treaty of Limerick in 1691 permitted thousands of Irish soldiers to depart for France. Remembered as the Wild Geese, they entered the service of Louis XIV and established a durable Irish military presence on the Continent. The Stuart royal family likewise maintained its court in exile in France. The resulting networks of patronage and loyalty connected Irish Catholic families, Scottish Jacobites and the French monarchy. They offer a much better documented model of the transmission of political and military traditions than stories of an uninterrupted medieval secret order.

It was from this world that one of the most consequential literary constructions in the history of Freemasonry emerged. Andrew Michael Ramsay, a Scottish convert to Catholicism and tutor to the Stuart princes during their exile, became a prominent figure in French Masonic circles. In his oration of 1736–37, Ramsay represented Freemasonry as the heir of an international brotherhood formed by crusaders in the Holy Land. He described its association with the Knights of St John and its preservation among the Scots entrusted with the protection of French kings. Later Masonic writers developed this crusading pedigree into the more specific assertion of Templar descent.
That distinction is essential. Ramsay’s claim cannot prove the survival of medieval Templars in an eighteenth-century lodge. It proves something more useful for the history of fraternities: the deliberate construction of a chivalric ancestry in the very Franco-Scottish milieu where memories of exile, military service and disputed sovereignty remained politically significant. A lodge could adopt the language of an ancient order, recognize its members through ceremonies and understand itself as the custodian of obligations transcending ordinary national borders.
In Ireland, a different tradition of clandestine association developed in response to the structure of landownership. The Whiteboys of the 1760s employed white garments, nocturnal gatherings and collective intimidation against landlords and others who enforced an objectionable agrarian order. The Ribbon societies subsequently developed elaborate secret rituals and an associational culture sometimes described by historians as quasi-Masonic. As Irish communities emigrated, elements of that culture traveled with them. Ribbonism is documented in Britain and, to a lesser extent, in the United States and other parts of the Irish diaspora. The Pennsylvania Molly Maguires became the subject of a particularly bitter controversy over secret association, industrial violence and private detective work during the 1870s.
None of these Irish groups can simply be identified with the American Klan. The Catholic associational traditions of the Irish would in fact become targets of the Klan’s twentieth-century nativism. What the earlier record supplies is an evidence-based history of the circulation of disguises, vows, military loyalty and traditions of extralegal authority. That repertoire was available to very different political movements on both sides of the Atlantic. Its French counterpart was particularly visible in the religious fraternities of the old monarchy and the political societies that emerged after the Revolution.

Long before an American fraternity adopted a pointed hood, the garment was familiar throughout Catholic Europe. Lay penitential brotherhoods established in the Mediterranean maintained their own officers, chapels, treasuries and ceremonial obligations. They accompanied the dead to burial, cared for the sick and participated in the public religious life of cities. The individual penitent surrendered his visible identity in the course of these activities, appearing before God and his community as an otherwise anonymous member of a corporate religious body.
In Nice, the White Penitents trace their tradition to a Genoese fraternity constituted in 1306. Their own institutional history describes the construction of a chapel in the old city in 1518. Elsewhere in Provence there were white, black, grey and other fraternities distinguished partly by the color of their clothing. The form of the hood differed from town to town. Some closely covered the head and face; others rose into a conspicuous point. Historians of French penitential processions have recorded complaints about the anonymity of their members centuries before the hood acquired its modern political associations.
The religious meaning of this disguise is essential. A white hood in a Catholic procession cannot retrospectively be assigned the purpose of the white hood worn by a racial terrorist in Reconstruction. Nevertheless, a civilization already acquainted with the anonymous corporate body possessed a visual and ceremonial language that subsequent political movements could employ for entirely different ends. The historical problem is to determine when such borrowings actually occurred.
A more explicitly political form of clandestine association emerged from the upheavals of the French Revolution. In the aftermath of the Terror, as Jacobin authority collapsed and the Republic struggled to reassert control, armed bands attacked former revolutionary officials and their supporters in southern France. The White Terror of 1795 was accompanied by reports of Companies of Jesus, Companies of the Sun and the Companions of Jehu. The degree of centralized organization behind the violence remains disputed, but the killings and the counterrevolutionary climate were real. A contemporary observer could interpret the assaults as the acts of a subterranean political authority enforcing a judgment the state could not or would not execute.
France had inherited a long tradition of popular discipline outside the courts. Charivari, familiar throughout Europe, brought neighbors into the streets under disguises to ridicule or threaten people accused of violating communal expectations. Such rituals could be festive, punitive or violent. In the Pyrenees, beginning in 1829, men disguised as women and known as the Demoiselles resisted new forest regulations. The conflict continued for years. They were defending customary access to resources, not establishing a racial order, but the episode demonstrates how anonymity, collective action and local claims of legitimacy could converge in armed resistance to the state.
The revolutionary and counterrevolutionary secret societies operated in the same political environment. In 1810, during Napoleon’s reign, Ferdinand de Bertier de Sauvigny founded the Knights of the Faith, a clandestine Catholic royalist association dedicated to restoring the Bourbons. Bertier adapted organizational elements familiar from Freemasonry to an explicitly anti-Napoleonic purpose. After 1815, the Carbonari and their French counterparts in the Charbonnerie pursued objectives often opposed to those of the royalists. Their cells drew on initiatory oaths, allegory and networks of mutual recognition. Some conspirators sought liberal constitutional government, others republican revolution, and still others the restoration of a Napoleonic dynasty.
The Knights of the Faith and the Charbonnerie belonged to opposing political traditions, but their organizational methods could be adapted by either side. After Waterloo, the same vocabulary of initiation, military obligation and secret correspondence traveled with the displaced officers and political refugees who sought opportunities abroad. One of their destinations was the United States.

Joseph Bonaparte, formerly king of Naples and subsequently king of Spain, arrived in the United States in 1815. He established himself at Point Breeze near Bordentown, New Jersey, and maintained connections with French exiles and prominent Americans. The estate housed art, books and the remnants of a European court transplanted into a republic. When French visitors arrived, they encountered a member of a defeated dynasty living under the protection of the government that had purchased Louisiana from his brother scarcely twelve years earlier.

The settlement at Point Breeze was only the most visible portion of the Napoleonic emigration. Discharged officers, adventurers and refugees moved toward Philadelphia, Alabama, New Orleans and the disputed territories along the Spanish-American frontier. In Alabama the Vine and Olive Colony was founded under congressional land grants in 1817. Some of its participants hoped to reconstruct their lives as agricultural settlers; others entertained more ambitious schemes. Rafe Blaufarb’s study Bonapartists in the Borderlands reconstructs their connections with merchants, speculators, refugees from the Caribbean and the complicated politics of American expansion. It also cautions against accepting every story about an imperial restoration plot at face value.
General Charles Lallemand, who had served Napoleon, led one of the less conventional ventures. In 1818, his followers established Champ d’Asile near the Trinity River in territory claimed by Spain. Some financial assistance came through Jean Lafitte. French engravings circulated an extraordinarily romantic image of the colony, depicting defeated soldiers clearing land, building shelters and founding a settlement in an imagined American wilderness. The venture was short-lived. Spanish opposition, shortages and the difficulty of maintaining the settlement compelled its abandonment.Champ d’Asile, showing its redoubts, barracks and settlement plan. Perry-Castañeda Library Map Collection, University of Texas. Image source
Its failure should not obscure the unusual political possibilities that made such an enterprise conceivable. The territory between Louisiana, Spanish Texas and the emerging Mexican republic was unsettled in a diplomatic sense; it was, of course, already inhabited and politically contested by Indigenous nations. Entrepreneurs and officers could attempt to establish communities beyond the effective reach of existing governments. Their allegiances could reach across oceans. Schemes attributed to Bonapartist circles included the installation of Joseph on a Mexican throne, although Blaufarb questions the evidence for some of the more elaborate plans. In the world that produced the Texas colony, a military officer could simultaneously be an international refugee, a land entrepreneur and a political conspirator.
The American frontier in the first half of the nineteenth century accommodated many experiments in alternative sovereignty. A particularly unexpected connection between the Napoleonic diaspora and one of those experiments survives in a set of Egyptian antiquities.

In 1835, an exhibit of Egyptian mummies and papyri reached Kirtland, Ohio. Joseph Smith and his associates acquired part of the collection. Smith began producing the text eventually published as the Book of Abraham in 1842. Its physical source materials had passed through the commercial network surrounding Bernardino Drovetti, the Italian-born diplomat appointed French consul in Egypt during the Napoleonic period. Antonio Lebolo, who had sided with the defeated Napoleonic order, went to Egypt and excavated antiquities while working with Drovetti. Michael Chandler subsequently exhibited the collection in the United States.
The objects can be followed from Egyptian excavation to Ohio. The political implications of their passage are less certain: the antiquities trade does not establish that Smith was part of a Bonapartist enterprise. What is certain is that the material culture of Napoleon’s Egyptian expedition entered the scriptures of a new American religion at a moment when that religion was beginning to formulate its own understanding of the ancient world.


There was already a considerable body of American literature concerned with another ancient civilization: Israel. The eighteenth-century trader James Adair published his History of the American Indians in 1775, proposing that Indigenous peoples descended from ancient Israelites. Elias Boudinot, a former president of the Continental Congress, pursued related arguments in A Star in the West in 1816. Ethan Smith’s View of the Hebrews, published in 1823 and expanded in 1825, sought parallels between biblical history and the Indigenous societies of North America. These works belonged to a longstanding effort to bring the American continent into the chronology of sacred history.
In Genesis, the struggle between Jacob and Esau is a struggle over inheritance. Esau sells his birthright; Jacob receives the blessing of Isaac; and the two brothers become the ancestors of rival peoples. By assigning one of these families to the inhabitants of America, a theologian could turn the political question of who was entitled to the land into a question of biblical law. The theories identifying Native peoples with Jacob’s descendants and those identifying them with Esau could therefore have radically different consequences, even though neither is supported as a historical account of Indigenous ancestry.
The most striking document in this respect is an unpublished treatise composed by a Maryland Jesuit, Joseph P. Mobberly, in 1823. His manuscript survives in the Georgetown University archives under the title Treatise on Slavery — Cham. In a passage concerning the ancestry of Indigenous Americans, Mobberly wrote that he considered it reasonable to suppose they descended from Esau. His argument proceeds through the biblical history of Esau’s birthright, the red appearance associated with him, his descendants in Edom and the relationship between the families of Esau and Ishmael.
Mobberly read the European acquisition of Indigenous land in terms of Esau’s sale of his birthright and the prophecies concerning the two sons of Isaac. He was attempting to furnish a theological explanation for the dispossession taking place around him. The manuscript belongs to a larger work defending and explaining racial slavery. It provides evidence of what a particular American religious writer believed, rather than any evidence that Native Americans were actually descended from the Edomites. The Indigenous peoples of the Americas possessed their own histories and genealogies independent of these European attempts to interpret them.

Another striking example emerged from a very different religious tradition. In 1825, Mordecai Manuel Noah inaugurated his proposed Jewish refuge, Ararat, on Grand Island in New York. The settlement was never realized as envisioned. Noah was interested in the biblical possibilities of America and later published a discourse on the Lost Tribes of Israel. His territorial project demonstrates the extraordinary range of political proposals circulating in the early republic. The American continent might provide a refuge, a site of restoration or a new religious homeland, depending upon the community interpreting it.
Historian Matthew W. Dougherty’s Lost Tribes Found treats these stories as part of the formation of American religious nationalism. They circulated among Anglo-American Protestants, Jews, Latter-day Saints and some Indigenous people, who did not necessarily understand them in the same way. They furnished vocabularies for imagining the political future of the United States and for contesting the authority of its expanding government. Mobberly’s Edomite interpretation belongs in that history as a competing genealogy. In the Bible, Esau and Jacob are brothers, but they represent different lines of inheritance. The difference was consequential for writers attempting to assign a sacred meaning to American land.
Joseph Smith’s Book of Mormon, published in 1830, placed the descendants of ancient Israelites at the center of its account of the American continent. Lehi’s family was associated with the line of Joseph, and the Lamanites became integral to the new religion’s expectation of the restoration of Israel. This differed from Mobberly’s assignment of Indigenous Americans to Edom. Both interpretations nonetheless attempted to place America within the same scriptural universe. Smith also employed the term Idumea in an 1831 revelation, using it as a figure for the world subject to divine judgment.
There was another biblical theme in the book that belonged squarely to the political concerns of the early republic. Its account of the Gadianton robbers described secret oaths and combinations capable of corrupting government from within. In 1826, the disappearance of William Morgan after he threatened to disclose Masonic rituals had already set western New York ablaze with anti-Masonic agitation. The phrase “secret combinations” was also employed in legal and political contexts unrelated to Masonry; scholars dispute whether Smith was making a specific reference to the fraternity. What matters here is that the fear of an oath-bound government operating inside the public government was present in Mormon scripture years before the Danite affair.

The political environment in which Mormonism developed made these questions unusually urgent. In 1830 Congress adopted the Indian Removal Act. Over the following decade, the forced relocation of Native nations transformed the lands west of the Mississippi into a heavily contested region. Federal authorities negotiated treaties, missionaries pursued conversions and settlers crossed or occupied the boundaries of Indigenous territory. Within that upheaval, the new Mormon movement proclaimed the possibility of a gathering of Israel and a sacred community in western Missouri.
By 1838, the Latter-day Saints had become embroiled in a violent conflict with other settlers. They had already been expelled from Jackson County in 1833. The subsequent movement of Mormon communities into northern Missouri did not resolve the antagonism. By the summer of 1838, a secret association had formed among the Saints, initially described in surviving documents as the Society of the Daughter of Zion and subsequently known as the Danites.
Sampson Avard, who participated in the organization and later testified against Mormon leaders, supplied Missouri authorities with an alleged constitution. The document is reproduced in the Joseph Smith Papers. The association’s organization drew on familiar American fraternal practices, but its name and some of its participants’ explanations were biblical. Joseph Smith later associated the word Danite with Judges 18 and the defense of the Saints against their enemies. The chapter concerns a tribe of ancient Israel searching for a territorial inheritance and using armed force to obtain it. In Missouri, a reference to Dan could carry both military and scriptural meaning.

The Danites are known principally through contested testimony, retrospective accounts and the surviving organizational document. Avard had reasons to minimize his own responsibility and implicate others. Joseph Smith’s degree of approval and control remains disputed. The violence surrounding the 1838 conflict, including Mormon attacks and acts of retaliation against Mormon settlements, is not in dispute. Governor Lilburn Boggs’s executive order directing that the Mormons be driven from the state or exterminated supplied a particularly brutal example of the coercive authority being exercised against the community.

After their expulsion, the Saints constructed another settlement in Illinois. Nauvoo possessed an unusually broad municipal charter, a city court and a militia known as the Nauvoo Legion. Joseph Smith held the rank of lieutenant general. Uniformed men assembled on parade grounds, elected officers and participated in the defense of a city whose inhabitants understood themselves as the beneficiaries of religious promises extending beyond the institutions of the American republic.
The relationship with Masonry complicates any simple account of the Danites as an anti-Masonic movement. In March 1842 Smith himself entered Freemasonry at Nauvoo. The Masonic lodge and municipal institutions developed alongside his increasingly elaborate religious offices. The resulting political community could be viewed by its residents as a refuge from mob violence and by its opponents as a state within a state. Both responses shaped the events that followed; the religious vocabulary alone cannot tell us which accusations were justified.
In March 1844, Smith established the Council of Fifty. For generations its surviving minutes were inaccessible to most researchers. Their publication in 2016 through the Joseph Smith Papers made it possible to examine its political deliberations in detail. Members conceived the council as the beginning of an earthly government of the kingdom of God. Its activities included discussions of constitutional organization, settlement beyond the United States, Smith’s presidential candidacy and the future relationship between the Saints and Indigenous nations.

On April 11, 1844, the council sustained Smith in a sacred governing capacity. Months later he was killed at Carthage, Illinois. Brigham Young’s reorganization of the council took place amid another impending expulsion. On March 1, 1845, Lewis Dana, an Oneida member of the church, was temporarily admitted. Council members discussed a mission to the Indian Territory to seek allies and a new home. Dana and other participants traveled west, and their reports entered the council’s confidential records.
This episode is crucial because it moves the discussion out of abstract scripture. The Mormon leadership was treating biblical kinship as a basis for actual diplomacy. Dana was a person with his own community, relationships and religious convictions, and the nations contacted by the council had their own political interests. The council’s ambitions cannot be assumed to constitute those nations’ consent. The undertaking nevertheless shows that a project of religious territorial organization was being actively considered by the same movement whose early paramilitary association would later be reduced in popular memory to images of hooded assassins.

The next inhabitants of Nauvoo introduced a remarkable French connection. Étienne Cabet had participated in the political culture of the French Restoration, including the Charbonnerie. A lawyer, republican journalist and eventual advocate of communal socialism, he developed his vision of a collective society in the novel Voyage en Icarie. His followers set out for America in 1848, initially attempting a settlement in Texas. Disease, supply problems and the difficulties of the project forced the colonists to retreat. An advance party discovered the properties abandoned by the Mormons at Nauvoo, and in 1849 the Icarians established themselves there.
Cabet and his followers were not the political successors of Joseph Smith; they had a very different understanding of property, religion and authority. But the same physical town that had housed the Mormon kingdom became the headquarters of a French communal experiment. Within a generation, Texas had attracted both Napoleonic officers and French utopian socialists, and the latter had taken possession of a settlement created by an American religious separatist movement. That geographical conjunction is better documented than any claim that a secret French order directed the Danites.
The history of Nauvoo thus belongs to an international history of political settlement. A community could fail, be expelled or abandon its territory, and the buildings could be inherited by another group with a wholly different program. Such successions were ordinary features of a continent undergoing rapid expansion. They also help explain why the surviving material landscape sometimes preserves relationships that cut across the categories by which historians ordinarily organize the nineteenth century.

In 1855 the name Danite reappeared in a setting that had little to do with the Mormon kingdom. The Kansas-Nebraska Act had placed the question of slavery in the territories under the principle of popular sovereignty. Both advocates and opponents of slavery rushed to Kansas, hoping to control its institutions and determine its constitutional future. Armed associations formed on both sides. Among the Free-State organizations was the Kansas Legion, also known as the Danites.
A constitution and ritual of the Kansas Legion, dated April 4, 1855, was published in the congressional investigation of territorial affairs. Its presence in the official record provides a valuable point of comparison with the Danite constitution from Missouri. Here again were military grades, obligations of secrecy and an organized political purpose. James Henry Lane, a former Indiana lieutenant governor and congressman, became one of the most prominent leaders of the Kansas Free-State movement. The political commitments of the Kansas Legion differed sharply from the later white supremacist Klan. The common name and methods do not establish that the Kansas body descended from the Mormon society.
Lane’s career illustrates the proximity of frontier political fraternity and federal power. In April 1861, when Abraham Lincoln’s government faced the threat of an attack on Washington, Lane recruited a body of Kansas volunteers known as the Frontier Guard. For a brief period they were quartered at the White House. Men drawn from the violent territorial struggle had become protectors of the president of the United States.
There was also an antebellum order whose political objectives point more directly toward the Confederacy and Reconstruction. George W. L. Bickley’s Knights of the Golden Circle envisaged a slaveholding empire encompassing Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean. It subsequently became involved with Southern secession. David C. Keehn’s history of the order traces how its armed intimidation and clandestine political associations foreshadowed tactics used by Reconstruction-era extremists. This is a more persuasive place to look for the political antecedents of the Klan than in the Kansas Danites, whose Free-State cause stood in opposition to Bickley’s program. The Americas that the Bonapartist exiles had once considered a theater for new kingdoms remained a theater for imperial schemes, now explicitly organized around slavery.
Between Kansas and the Civil War came an event that profoundly influenced the public image of Mormon authority. In September 1857, Mormon militiamen and some Paiute participants attacked an emigrant wagon train at Mountain Meadows in southern Utah. Approximately 120 people were murdered. The perpetrators attempted to place responsibility upon the Indigenous participants and conceal the central role of the militia. Subsequent investigations and the trial of John D. Lee revealed elements of the deception. The episode was a genuine atrocity, and the cover story exploited an existing racial narrative about Native violence on the frontier.
The event demonstrates the danger of assuming a uniform meaning for biblical kinship. Mormon leaders could envision Indigenous nations as relatives within sacred history, yet white Mormon militiamen could employ Indigenous identity as a device to conceal their own crimes. Throughout the century, similar contradictions appeared in the relationship between American religious mythology and the treatment of Native peoples. The Improved Order of Red Men, organized under that name in Baltimore in 1834, developed a fraternal system based on romanticized Indigenous imagery while excluding nonwhite members for much of its history. White Americans could declare themselves symbolic heirs to Indigenous traditions while denying Indigenous communities political rights.

When the first Ku Klux Klan was organized in Pulaski, Tennessee, in late 1865 or early 1866, the South was emerging from a war fought to preserve and expand slavery. Former Confederate soldiers participated in the founding club. As the organization spread, its clandestine networks attacked Black citizens, Republican officials, educators, Unionists and others associated with the new political order. Night riding and disguise were used to prevent identification and magnify the terror experienced by victims. The Klan was part of a white supremacist counterrevolution against emancipation and Reconstruction.
This background rules out any explanation that substitutes a European secret society for the actual political conditions of the American South. The Klan drew its recruits and purpose from the defeated Confederacy. The historical question of its costume and organizational form remains open to a broader set of influences. Historian Elaine Frantz Parsons has emphasized the theatrical dimensions of the first Klan. Its disguises were heterogeneous. Masks, military remnants, horns, colored cloth, improvised gowns and extraordinary headwear appeared in the surviving representations. The uniform white outfit now regarded as the quintessential Klan costume was largely standardized by the later revival.

Katherine J. Lennard’s study Uniform Threat examines a particularly plausible route for the pointed hat. French-speaking settlers brought traditions of the capuchon to North America. In the Acadian communities of Louisiana, rural Mardi Gras developed its own forms of disguise, costumes and tall pointed headwear. Lennard, drawing on Parsons’s research, considers these carnival traditions a likely influence on Reconstruction Klan costume. A group of masked riders could be understood by contemporaries within a familiar repertoire of holiday theater, ghost stories and communal discipline. The terror produced by transforming such traditions into instruments of political assault was part of the perpetrators’ power.
The history of the Knights of the White Camellia offers a related Louisiana example. Established in 1867 under the leadership of Alcibiades DeBlanc, the association combined secrecy and elaborate initiation with white supremacist political objectives. It denied being part of the Tennessee Klan, and its organization should not be collapsed into that of the Klan proper. Louisiana’s own tradition of political fraternities, along with antebellum organizations such as the Knights of the Golden Circle, offers another field in which to test possible institutional continuities. Historians have traced Confederate-era militancy into the Reconstruction underground, but a French chain of command has not emerged from that evidence.

Even before the revival of the Klan in 1915, the 1911 edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica compared the American organization with the French confréries, Carbonari, Freemasonry and several other European secret societies. That comparison was typological rather than a claim of descent, and the article reflected some of the racial prejudices of its era. Nevertheless, it shows that the European comparison was not invented by later writers.
The exchange of imagery across the Atlantic was already taking place during Reconstruction. On June 8, 1868, the French illustrated periodical L’Événement illustré published an illustration of the Ku Klux Klan. That date is especially important in relation to the hooded figures that appeared in Femmes françaises in 1945. The French public did not need to encounter Mormon cinema or the twentieth-century Klan before learning of its existence. The original American organization was already a subject of French illustration in the 1860s.
That same spring, another periodical approached the Klan through an explicitly biblical framework. On May 30, 1868, the Latter-day Saints’ Millennial Star carried an article entitled Secret Combinations. It discussed the Klan, the Loyal League, the Grand Army of the Republic and Fenianism in relation to the problem of secret political associations. Its religious frame of reference was the Book of Mormon, whose narrative warns repeatedly about oath-bound conspiracies organized for power and gain. Rather than establishing the Church as the ancestor of the Klan, the article shows a Mormon writer interpreting the new organization through a scriptural system that long preceded it.
The federal response to the Klan coincided with a major change in the constitutional treatment of Native nations. In March 1871, Congress ended the practice of making new treaties with Indigenous tribes as independent political entities, while preserving obligations arising from existing treaties. In April, the Ku Klux Klan Act expanded the federal government’s ability to prosecute political violence and protect civil rights. Under President Grant, federal authorities suppressed much of the first Klan. White supremacist violence continued through other organizations, including the White League and the Red Shirts, and the eventual collapse of Reconstruction enabled the establishment of Jim Crow.
In April 1871 the Grant administration also acquired new powers to suppress the Klan through the Enforcement Acts. The two developments belonged to distinct political struggles: the protection of Black citizenship against terror and the restriction of formal treaty relations with Native nations. Their proximity in time is significant for the history of federal consolidation, but the laws supply no evidence of a coordinated project to erase a biblical genealogy. The subsequent history of Utah would bring another claim to political autonomy into direct conflict with Washington.
The nineteenth-century contest over alternative territorial arrangements was increasingly being resolved within federal institutions. The idea that America contained independent or potentially independent sacred political communities lost much of its earlier practical force. Indigenous sovereignty certainly did not disappear, and Native nations continued to defend their own authority and treaty rights. Mormon biblical beliefs likewise continued. The terms under which these claims could be pursued had changed.
The Poland Act of 1874 rearranged judicial authority in Utah, limiting the jurisdiction of local probate courts. The Edmunds–Tucker Act of 1887 went further, disincorporating the LDS Church and targeting its property and polygamous institutions. Utah became a state in 1896. Over the period in which federal authority expanded across these territories, the religious kingdom envisioned in the private meetings at Nauvoo ceased to be a practical alternative form of government. Its scriptural claims persisted. The political machinery that had once made them an immediate question of diplomacy and jurisdiction did not survive in its original form.
The period also saw changes in the interpretation of America’s ancient past. Archaeological research, professional ethnology and new scientific ideas challenged the earlier enthusiasm for biblical explanations of Indigenous ancestry. Some of these newer disciplines imported their own deeply racist assumptions. In that atmosphere the older literature of lost tribes and ancient Israelites became less central to mainstream accounts of the nation’s origins. This development had multiple causes; no evidence presently demonstrates that the Danites or the Klan coordinated an effort to suppress the Esau tradition. What can be demonstrated with unusual clarity is the later manufacture of a false association between the two organizations.
In 1915, D. W. Griffith’s film The Birth of a Nation gave an immense American audience a nostalgic account of the Confederacy and a racist representation of Reconstruction. It cast the Klan as the heroic instrument of Southern redemption. The film helped inspire William Joseph Simmons’s revival of the organization at Stone Mountain, Georgia, later that year. The revival adopted a far more uniform visual language than that which had characterized many members of the original Reconstruction societies. Costumes became commercially manufactured objects of mass membership and public spectacle.
The Scottish dimension of Griffith’s film can be traced directly to the books from which it was adapted. In 1810, Walter Scott had published The Lady of the Lake, whose third canto described a fiery cross carried among the Highland clans as a summons to arms. Scott was one of the most influential literary interpreters of chivalry and historical romance in the nineteenth-century English-speaking world. His work gave readers on both sides of the Atlantic a romantic vocabulary for imagining the feudal past.
Thomas Dixon’s 1905 novel The Clansman made the connection explicit. His fictional Southern leaders claimed kinship with the Scottish clans and employed what Dixon called the old Scottish rite of the fiery cross. The novel presents the ceremony as the awakening of ancestral loyalties, transposing an imagined Highland past into the political struggles of Reconstruction. Dixon’s racial fantasy also drew upon the Scots-Irish frontier mythology, identifying the white South with a people supposedly driven from Britain into the American wilderness.
The burning cross was subsequently incorporated into Griffith’s 1915 film and adopted by the revived Klan. The Supreme Court’s historical discussion in Virginia v. Black (2003) identifies this literary and cinematic sequence. The familiar ritual was not a defining practice of the original Reconstruction Klan. It was a later invention endowed with the authority of a much older custom. The name itself had already combined a Greek word for a circle with the Gaelic-derived word clan. The etymology supplied Dixon with an invitation to invent an entire ancestral history.
There is a revealing symmetry between Ramsay and Dixon, despite their radically different purposes. Ramsay presented the eighteenth-century lodge as the heir to Crusader knighthood; Dixon presented the twentieth-century image of the Klan as the heir to Highland clan warfare. In each case the construction of a pedigree gave a modern fraternity an apparently ancient political identity. The French Arthurian romances, the later Scottish Templar legends and the American film culture of the early twentieth century thus belong to a history of the transmission and reuse of chivalric mythology, even where they cannot be joined by a continuous membership roll.
Two years later, American audiences saw A Mormon Maid, directed by Robert Z. Leonard. Set in a sensationalized version of nineteenth-century Utah, it portrayed the Danites as a secret body of armed religious enforcers. The movie dressed its supposed Danites in robes virtually identical to the cinematic Klan costumes, replacing the cross emblem with an eye. An intertitle expressly claimed that the Klan had subsequently adopted the Danite costume. Film historians have identified that connection as fabricated. The publicity was designed to capitalize on Griffith’s enormous success and contemporary anti-Mormon sentiment. In some advertising, the relationship to The Birth of a Nation was overt.
“This costume, but with a cross substituted for the ‘Eye,’ was later adopted by the Ku Klux Klan.”Intertitle, A Mormon Maid (1917), as transcribed in film histories
The direction of the borrowing is the important thing. Griffith’s film, drawn from Thomas Dixon’s novels, had given twentieth-century audiences a standardized, heroic image of the Klan that bore only a partial resemblance to the varied disguises depicted in 1868. A Mormon Maid took the recognizable costume and moved it backward into Mormon history. It then treated that retrospective invention as the source of the later uniform. The screen had collapsed a century of political and religious history into a familiar piece of clothing.
The transformation need not have been the work of a single secret organization to have historical consequences. The commercial motive is visible: film historians have documented the promotion of A Mormon Maid through its association with Griffith’s success. Its historical claim encouraged audiences to remember religious sovereignty as the private violence of sinister religious authorities, even as the revived Klan presented its own nativist program as a patriotic and Protestant defense of American institutions.
At the same time, the second Klan developed a public program radically broader than that of the original Southern fraternity. It became a national Protestant nativist movement, attacking Catholics, Jews, immigrants and Black Americans. Its demonstrations reached the streets of Washington. Indiana became one of its most notorious strongholds. The new Klan’s nationalism was expressed through an exclusive understanding of Christianity and citizenship. That religious program was substantially different from an antebellum theory that regarded Native Americans as participants in the restoration of ancient Israel, even though biblical ideas had been employed to justify racial exclusion long before Reconstruction.
The older biblical interpretations did not simply disappear. They survived within Mormonism and other religious traditions, alongside theories of racial hierarchy that had existed well before the Civil War. What changed was their political setting. The descendants of ancient Israel in the territorial imagination of the antebellum reformers, the independent Indigenous nations and the members of a church claiming the right to establish a kingdom were increasingly governed within a single federal framework. The Klan helped enforce a racial order in part of that framework, and popular culture helped determine which older claims Americans would remember.

In France, the collapse of parliamentary confidence during the 1930s produced another clandestine political movement. Eugène Deloncle and his associates organized the conspiracy known as La Cagoule, a far-right group implicated in arms trafficking, assassinations and plans to overthrow the Republic. Reports associate its Nice affiliate, the Chevaliers du Glaive, with Klan-like ceremonial imagery. The organization as a whole did not necessarily wear hoods routinely, and the nickname itself came from outside the group. This distinction matters because the most familiar representation of a clandestine society may tell us more about its enemies and its publicity than about its daily operation.
By then France had had almost seventy years in which to become acquainted with the American Klan. The French engraving of June 1868 establishes the early arrival of that imagery; Hollywood and the revived Klan’s public marches gave it a much greater circulation. The hood had crossed the Atlantic in both religious and political forms, and its meaning changed with the movement that claimed it.
The scandal of synarchism developed after the French defeat in 1940. A purported secret pact and reports of a Mouvement Synarchique d’Empire circulated during the Vichy regime. Allegations centered on Jean Coutrot, a technocratic engineer, and the networks surrounding Banque Worms and government officials. Writers on the subject have differed sharply over the reality and structure of the alleged organization. The concentration of industrial and financial administrators in the Vichy government was real; the existence of a single directing command was far more difficult to prove. La Cagoule had its own documented history of violent activity, and the existence of personal and political overlaps does not settle the allegation that it was an armed branch of a synarchist order.
By August 1945, the Resistance newspaper could place the hooded fraternity above an article about bankers and industrialists. Simone Badia was writing at a moment when the institutional future of France remained unsettled. Her question about the survival of Vichy’s administrators concerned the politics of liberation itself. The historical image encapsulated a suspicion that visible governments were only part of the political structure, and that private men could maintain another order beneath them.
Look again at the illustration of 1945. There are no named men in its little procession; no bank, ministry or industrial corporation wears an identifying label. It is the visual anonymity that makes the accusation so effective. Badia is asking her readers to imagine that the public authority of Vichy was administered by a private fraternity and that the fraternity survived the fall of the government. Whether that specific allegation about synarchy was true is a matter for the banking records, police reports and archives of the Cagoule.
The longer history presents a different problem. The papyri of Joseph Smith really did reach America through the Napoleonic antiquities trade. A veteran of the French secret-society world really did settle in the abandoned Mormon town. The Council of Fifty really did discuss a kingdom and dispatch an Indigenous diplomatic mission. French readers really did see images of the Klan in 1868, and the motion-picture industry really did manufacture a Danite genealogy for its modern costume. These connections can be documented without inventing a single chain of command between them.
The medieval period complicates the meaning of the word origins in the title of this investigation. Some elements of the Klan’s visual and literary identity have identifiable European antecedents; others were fabricated in the United States and subsequently exported back to Europe. The French Arthurian tradition, the Auld Alliance, the Irish and Scottish exile communities, Ramsay’s Masonic oration, the French colonial capuchon and Dixon’s Scottish romance illustrate different kinds of transmission. The political organization founded at Pulaski, by contrast, arose from the particular racial and political struggle of American Reconstruction. The historical question is how that organization and its successors acquired the European imagery through which they represented themselves, and how it became available in turn to the political conspiracies of modern France.
In 1945, the little drawing in Femmes françaises had acquired the power to summarize an entire theory of secret government. In 1917 a similar drawing could have been used to explain the history of the Mormons. In 1583 the same garment had appeared in a religious procession attended by a French king. What the hood had covered across those centuries was not one continuous society but a succession of different claims to authority. The work of recovering those claims begins where the illustration leaves off.