
“Your child is in Ohio.”
That, according to a complaint filed against a firm of Indianapolis undertakers, was the answer given to a husband and wife who had entrusted the body of their daughter to the funeral establishment in December 1884. They had arranged for the child to be kept in a secure vault until they were prepared to bury her. When they returned the following spring, the body was gone. They had made no arrangements for its transportation to Ohio and had given no one permission to bury it elsewhere.
The undertakers’ explanation, preserved in the Indiana Supreme Court’s opinion, was somewhat more complicated. Their vault held other children of approximately the same age, prepared for interment in much the same manner. One of the coffins had been shipped away in place of another. By May 4, 1885, the firm said it had discovered that the child had been buried in a place called Ohio, in Pennsylvania. The undertakers offered to recover the body and return it by express at their own expense. They put the cost of the return shipment at fifty dollars, more than twice the twenty dollars they said they were owed for their original services. The parents filed suit on May 5. According to the firm’s answer, the child was returned and buried later that month.

On October 30, 1890, in Renihan v. Wright, the Indiana Supreme Court affirmed the judgment against the undertakers. It recognized the right of the surviving relatives to custody and burial of the deceased and approved an instruction allowing the jury to consider the parents’ mental anguish. The return of the child did not itself extinguish the claim. The law had recognized an injury arising from the violation of a family’s right to the body of one of its members.
That recognition had a complicated afterlife. In 1937, another Indiana couple sued an undertaker who, they alleged, had promised to photograph their deceased daughter before burial and failed to do so. They had no other photograph of the child. In Plummer v. Hollis, the state Supreme Court upheld a demurrer to their complaint, which meant its allegations were taken as true for purposes of deciding the legal question, not established as facts at trial. The court rejected recovery for mental suffering alone arising from the negligent breach of contract. Justice Jordan, dissenting in a 1901 case involving Western Union, had already observed that the majority’s decision necessarily overruled Renihan. The 1937 court adopted his reading. The law’s treatment of grief had changed, but the underlying commercial relationship remained recognizable: a family had entrusted a professional with preserving something that would otherwise be irretrievable.
Consider the scope of the original undertaking. The Indianapolis firm had accepted a body, placed it in a communal vault, maintained it for a period of months and undertaken to release it when instructed. It also had access to the commercial transportation system through which the body of a child could be sent hundreds of miles away and brought back again. The death itself had occurred at a specific moment; almost everything that happened afterward depended upon the accuracy of the firm’s records, the identity of the person entitled to give instructions and its ability to fulfill a promise over time.
There is an entire history concealed within the ordinary expression funeral arrangements. Death activates insurance contracts, wills, trusts, cemetery agreements and obligations established through membership in churches and fraternal organizations. Debts must be paid, property administered and dependents provided for. The funeral director has a distinct legal role from the executor, but both work in a system in which instructions survive the person or household that issued them. By the nineteenth century the physical custody of the body, the financial administration of the estate and the manufacture of its permanent memorial had become related branches of an increasingly industrial economy. The people who built that economy can be found in the records of Swiss banking houses, American furniture factories, Indiana limestone quarries and the institutions responsible for the burial of Abraham Lincoln.

At Petit-Chasseur, near Sion in the Swiss canton of Valais, archaeological excavations have uncovered funerary structures and anthropomorphic stone stelae from the late Neolithic and Bell Beaker periods. Their surfaces depict human forms, clothing, ornaments and weapons. Some were reused in later burial structures. Whatever individual meanings their makers attached to them, these stones survived the communities that produced them, and their subsequent use demonstrates that the objects themselves had lives extending beyond their original manufacture. The tradition of recording human identity in stone is among the oldest surviving features of funerary culture. In later centuries the names and dates engraved on a headstone could preserve information that disappeared from every other local record.
European religious art developed its own vocabulary of mortality: skeletons, hourglasses, clocks and the Dance of Death. In Geneva, those motifs entered a manufacturing industry concerned with the actual measurement of time. Goldsmiths, engravers and watchmakers shared technical skills, and Geneva’s watchmakers organized their guild in 1601. One of their more unusual products was the skull watch, an object belonging to the memento mori tradition. The example in the Metropolitan Museum of Art carries the mechanism of Isaac Penard, a Genevan watchmaker apprenticed to Jacques Sermand in 1632. Its movement dates to about 1650, while the silver skull enclosing it dates to approximately 1810–20. The museum attributes the later case, tentatively, to the firm of Moulinié, Bautte & Moynier. The watch as it exists today was assembled across more than a century and a half of European manufacturing history. Someone gave an old mechanism a new body.

In 1704, the Genevan mathematician Nicolas Fatio de Duillier obtained an English patent with the watchmakers Peter and Jacob Debaufre for a process of piercing gemstones for use inside mechanical watches. Fatio moved in Isaac Newton’s scientific circle and applied his knowledge of materials to the problem of friction at the pivots of a watch’s moving parts. The patent helped establish the practice of fitting cut jewels as bearings. Early jeweled movements were more common in England than in Switzerland; the practice later spread through the Swiss industry and into American watchmaking. Here the link between stoneworking and horology is a matter of manufacturing history: mineral material was shaped into a functional component of the clock itself.

The Swiss workshops also produced mechanisms capable of performing actions specified by their makers. In the eighteenth century Pierre Jaquet-Droz and his associates constructed three celebrated automata, including a mechanical figure capable of writing different texts. The Writer’s internal components encoded the motions of its hand. A commercial network connecting the workshop to the London dealer James Cox and his agents in Canton carried Swiss clocks, watches and elaborate mechanical objects to China. The machinery could continue to reproduce a selected sequence of movements long after the craftsman who assembled it was dead.

At roughly the same time, the bankers of Geneva discovered a way to turn the remaining years of a human life into a tradeable financial asset. In 1757 the French government began offering life annuities with rates that did not adequately distinguish the life expectancy of the person upon whose survival the payments depended. A purchaser could therefore obtain terms much more favorable to a young, healthy nominee than to an elderly one. Genevan investors exploited the difference by acquiring French government annuities on the lives of carefully selected young girls, often from prosperous local families and already past the danger of a first encounter with smallpox.

The banker Jacob Bouthillier Beaumont organized a syndicate for the annuity issue of 1763 and developed the arrangement further in 1771 into what became known as the Trente Demoiselles de Genève. The bankers collected annuities associated with multiple lives into investment pools, commonly employing thirty nominees, and sold interests in the resulting income to investors. Their Paris connections allowed them to purchase the securities and collect payments, while the selection of young lives and the pooling of risks made the investments less vulnerable to the premature death of any one person. Each girl’s continued existence had consequences for the income of a group of people who might never meet her. The relevant information was her age, health and survival, which had to be accounted for over years of payments.
Geneva’s eighteenth-century annuity trade required bankers to maintain financial accounts against the continuing survival of named individuals. This business preceded the founding of Swiss Re by nearly a century. Long before the establishment of a Swiss life reinsurer, the bankers of Geneva were already administering investments whose value depended upon the length of human lives.

Swiss movements did not power the earliest American bank time locks; their adoption followed decades of domestic manufacturing. James Sargent’s early bank vault time lock went into service in Morrison, Illinois, in May 1874. Once set, the mechanism prevented a vault from being opened before a specified interval had elapsed, even by someone who knew the correct combination. Early American time locks commonly used movements supplied by manufacturers such as E. Howard of Boston. Mosler’s own locks appeared around 1915–16 using American watch movements; its adoption of Swiss Recta movements came later, in the 1950s. Swiss movements became common in the American trade, and Sargent & Greenleaf continues to specify thirteen-jewel Swiss mechanisms in its mechanical time locks. The pierced gemstone patented by Fatio and the Debaufres in 1704 belongs to the same technological tradition that eventually controlled access to the assets of American banks.

The Swiss Colonization Society, organized in Cincinnati in 1856, established a settlement on the Ohio River in southern Indiana in 1858. The site offered timber, coal and river access. Initially called Helvetia, the settlement became Tell City. The Tell City Furniture Company was organized in 1859, and by 1885 the town contained twenty-six furniture factories. Its workforce drew on a wider Central European migration through Cincinnati. The 1885 county history identifies John Foerster, a director of the Cabinet Makers’ Union, as Prussian-born, and its agent Anton Paalz as German-born. Francis Sedletzky came from Bohemia via Cincinnati, joining the Tell City Furniture Company in 1859 and serving as its treasurer from 1860 to 1872. The Swiss-founded colony attracted craftsmen and investors from well beyond Switzerland.

Among the society’s members was John H. Schergens, born in Prussia in 1821. He had learned cabinetmaking before immigrating to the United States in 1848 and practiced the trade in Cincinnati before relocating to Tell City in 1858. The 1885 History of Warrick, Spencer, and Perry Counties, Indiana records that he worked as a carpenter and cabinetmaker, spent ten years in the furniture and chair manufacturing firm Combs, Hartman & Co., then entered the undertaking and picture-frame business. He also belonged to the Independent Order of Odd Fellows. Polk’s 1884–85 state business directory independently lists him as an undertaker in Tell City. A town history published in 2008 dates his combined undertaking establishment and furniture store to 1858, although that early date is difficult to reconcile with the occupational sequence given in the nineteenth-century biography. The earlier record establishes the sequence without requiring a precise founding date: a member of the Swiss Colonization Society who manufactured furniture subsequently became a funeral professional and belonged to a fraternity whose obligations included burying the dead.

Stoneworking underwent a related industrial expansion in southern Indiana. Before the great limestone quarries of Bedford achieved national prominence, the whetstone beds of Orange County supplied a distinctive sedimentary stone that was used for grave markers as well as sharpening tools. One historical survey identified nearly 1,800 Hindostan markers in 221 cemeteries across thirty Indiana counties and five Illinois counties. Later surveys have found examples farther afield. The early monument trade depended on the distribution of standard blocks or slabs from the quarry to craftsmen and communities throughout the region. The surviving headstones are also evidence of the geographical reach of an early Indiana shipping industry.

At Bedford, the quarry, dressing mill, railway and cemetery were assembled into a more formal industrial system. Stone from the Dark Hollow Quarry could be extracted in enormous blocks, shaped at the mill and dispatched to distant customers. Monument companies supplied carved gravestones, bases, statuary and cemetery vaults. Many standard designs sold by the local companies found their way into Green Hill Cemetery, where the products of the trade stood beside the graves of its manufacturers. The 1894 Bedford Stone Cutters Association Monument commemorates the men working in that industry.

One of Green Hill Cemetery’s principal benefactors was Colonel Archibald C. Voris, a lawyer, partner in the Dark Hollow Quarry enterprise and president of the cemetery association. The 1884 county history credits him, as a delegate to the Republican National Convention in Chicago in 1860, with helping secure Abraham Lincoln’s nomination. He developed quarry properties and organized the Bedford, Springville and Switz City narrow-gauge railroad to carry stone to market. In 1891 he became the founding president of the state-chartered Citizens Bank, which became Citizens National Bank in 1898, and in 1900 he helped organize the separate Citizens Trust Company, serving as its first president. In 1892, between the establishment of the bank and its conversion to a national charter, he financed the construction of the limestone receiving vault now known as the Voris Mausoleum.
It was built to hold bodies during the winter while graves could not conveniently be opened. A schedule adopted in April 1893 charged three dollars for the first month and two dollars for each subsequent month, with occupancy limited to three months. The income was intended for the improvement of the cemetery. The National Register nomination records the building’s limestone roof, classical columns and metal doors, and notes that it has long since ceased to be used for temporary interment. Its donor had interests in the quarrying and transportation of the material from which it was built, in the financial institutions of the town and in the organization that administered the property. Edmund B. Thornton, another cemetery board member, was an officer of Bedford Steam Stone Works and later held a leadership position at the same Citizens National Bank. Voris died in 1911 and was succeeded as bank president by his son Joseph R. Voris. A federal banking report lists Thornton as president in October 1927. The cemetery, the stone industry and the bank shared personnel across successive generations.
In Fort Wayne, the same era produced a case in which the building of a monument became one of the conditions of an inheritance. In 1869 Abraham G. Barnett, his brother John H. Barnett and Newton B. Freeman were partners in a paper mill. They needed capital and obtained financing from George P. Bissell. A complicated set of loans, bonds and mortgages followed. John Barnett died before those transactions had been fully resolved, leaving a will that entered probate in February 1872. His instructions directed Abraham to collect the income of his real estate until the debts and funeral expenses had been settled, a plot in Lindenwood Cemetery had been obtained and improved, the bodies of their parents had been moved there, and a monument had been erected. The succession contemplated in the will depended on the completion of the work.

Abraham carried out the burial arrangements and administered the estate’s affairs. Yet he never secured the formal appointment or letters testamentary required of him under Indiana law. When the creditor dispute reached the United States Supreme Court in 1888, the immediate question was whether a release of a mortgage that Abraham had signed was valid. The Court held that it was, because he had independent authority as the surviving joint creditor of the underlying debt. His signature describing himself as executor did not invalidate an act he could lawfully perform in another capacity. The decision did not grant him general authority to act as an unqualified executor. The dispute over the paper mill’s debts preserved the original funerary instructions in the published opinion of Wall v. Bissell. A man had ordered the relocation of his parents’ remains and the construction of their monument; his rents paid for it, and the terms of his estate became evidence in litigation involving the financing of an industrial enterprise.
The authority that a testamentary arrangement gives the deceased has long troubled the law. Restrictions on perpetuities developed in part to limit the duration of control exercised by earlier owners over future generations. The Barnett will shows why that question matters in ordinary affairs: rental income, the timing of a transfer and the movement of human remains could all be directed by one instrument.
The administration of death also provided an economic foundation for American fraternal institutions. The Independent Order of Odd Fellows, established in its American form at Baltimore in 1819, made assistance to the sick, burial of the dead and care of the orphan central obligations of membership. The 1884 History of Indianapolis and Marion County, Indiana reported that during the year ending in November 1883 the Indiana Grand Lodge’s funds had supplied $8,173.32 for burials, $3,334.58 for widowed households and $625.50 for educating orphans. The total recorded relief and charitable expenditure was $47,270.56. Membership created a financial relationship that could continue to benefit a household after the member’s death. Similar obligations and burial ceremonies developed within Freemasonry and other mutual-benefit societies.

The Rochester newspapers document the combination of furniture and funeral services before the Zimmerman family’s entry into the trade. An advertisement published in the Rochester Gazette on December 9, 1858, names Christian Hoover as a furniture manufacturer and dealer who also performed undertaking. In June 1867, Myers & Carpenter advertised their new cabinet shop, planing mill and shingle factory in the Rochester Standard, offering coffins and a hearse for funerals alongside furniture and building materials. The Zimmerman business developed within this established local trade. Valentine Zimmerman, a German immigrant who arrived in Rochester in 1865, initially operated a shoe factory and entered furniture and undertaking in 1879, according to a 1959 family obituary. The surviving Zimmerman Bros. Funeral Home traces its history to 1866, but the available accounts do not explain how that date relates to Valentine’s later entry into the business.
Rochester’s cemetery history supplies another, independently documented financial connection. The Rochester Mausoleum Company was incorporated on April 8, 1911, to construct and maintain community mausoleums. The directors met at the First National Bank of Rochester in 1916. The bank later acted as trustee of the company’s funds for more than twenty years, according to the allegations recorded when a case concerning the deteriorating building reached Fulton Circuit Court in 1970. The company had apparently been without functioning officers for over a decade. In April 1971, 124 bodies were removed from the mausoleum and reinterred together on the east side of the Odd Fellows Cemetery. The crypts had been sold decades earlier with the expectation of continuing care. Eventually a bank, a court and the surviving cemetery infrastructure had to deal with obligations that the original company could no longer fulfill.
The Lincoln family had confronted the uncertain permanence of cemetery arrangements more than a century earlier. John Hutchinson, a Springfield cabinetmaker and undertaker, established a private burial ground in 1843. He supplied coffins, made funeral arrangements and sold burial lots, bringing several stages of the business under his own management. In February 1850, the Lincolns buried their three-year-old son Edward Baker in his cemetery. The arrangement gave the family a designated burial place, but its continued existence depended on property rights and the development of the city around it.
By the Civil War, the ability to transport bodies over great distances had been transformed by railroads and embalming. Railroad employees, military officials, undertakers and local authorities had to coordinate the movement of bodies through multiple jurisdictions. This process required identifiable coffins, appropriate containers, reliable schedules and custody records. America’s railroads would not adopt standardized time zones until 1883. When Lincoln’s funeral train left Washington in April 1865, its passage was organized across systems that operated on different local clocks.

There were two coffins on the train. Willie Lincoln had died in the White House in 1862 and his remains had spent the intervening three years in a vault at Oak Hill Cemetery in Georgetown. He was removed from that vault to accompany his father to Springfield. On May 4, 1865, both were placed in the public receiving vault at Oak Ridge Cemetery. Mary Lincoln insisted upon Oak Ridge as her husband’s permanent burial place despite proposals to construct the monument nearer the center of town. The construction project required an interim arrangement. In December, Eddie’s body was removed from Hutchinson’s cemetery, and on December 21 the three members of the family were united in a new temporary vault. All three were transferred again in September 1871, when the permanent monument was nearing completion. The kind of facility that held Lincoln and Willie from May to December 1865 was the same kind of receiving vault that Voris, credited in his county biography with working for Lincoln’s nomination, financed at Bedford in 1892.

The Lincolns were among hundreds of Springfield households affected by the consolidation of the city’s burial grounds. An ordinance of 1866 prohibited additions to Hutchinson’s Cemetery and allowed the owners of its lots to exchange them for similarly sized property at Oak Ridge. Between 1865 and 1879, 652 bodies from Hutchinson’s and the old City Cemetery were reinterred at Oak Ridge. The property that had served as the resting place of some of Springfield’s earliest families eventually became the site of Springfield High School. Cemetery ownership could confer control of the physical resting place of the dead, but municipal authority, land transactions and urban growth could alter the arrangements long after the original burial.
In the same year that Lincoln and his sons were reunited, a new company in Zurich was taking on an institutional responsibility for death on an international scale. Swiss Re had been established in December 1863, following the Glarus fire of 1861 and concerns over the capacity of domestic insurers to absorb heavy losses. The founding interests included Helvetia Insurance, Credit Suisse, Basler Handelsbank and Schweizerischer Lloyd. On June 1, 1865, Swiss Re signed its first life reinsurance treaty with Basle Life. The arrangements enabled an insurer to transfer a portion of its financial risk to another company, allowing mortality obligations to be distributed across a much larger financial organization. Unlike the eighteenth-century Genevan annuity investors, who profited from the continuing survival of selected nominees, a life insurer generally incurred a payment obligation when an insured person died. Both businesses depended on reliable information about mortality and the administration of contracts over extended periods.

Forty years later, a group of Indiana businessmen organized the Lincoln National Life Insurance Company in Fort Wayne. Incorporated on June 12, 1905, the company adopted the name of the assassinated president as the basis of its public identity. On July 28, company organizer Arthur F. Hall wrote to Robert Todd Lincoln seeking permission to use his father’s name and portrait. Robert replied on August 3, approving the use of the likeness and enclosing a photograph. The image of a man who had been dead for forty years would appear on documents issued by a company whose business consisted of financial promises that frequently matured upon the death of its customers.
On July 30, 2001, Swiss Re and Lincoln National Corporation announced that the Zurich reinsurer had agreed to acquire Lincoln Re, Lincoln National’s reinsurance business headquartered in Fort Wayne, for two billion dollars. The transaction was completed on December 7. A company that had entered life reinsurance four weeks after Lincoln’s initial interment at Oak Ridge thereby acquired the reinsurance operation of an Indiana company established under his name. The transaction occurred in the city where the Barnett estate’s funeral instructions had become entangled with industrial finance and mortgage law. It brings the Swiss and Indiana strands of this history together through an actual corporate acquisition. The financial obligations being transferred concerned the lives and deaths of individuals whom most of the people negotiating the transaction would never meet.
The most intimate expression of the responsibility assumed by these institutions can still be found at Oak Ridge Cemetery. In October 1874, John Carroll Power was appointed the first custodian of the Lincoln Tomb. He maintained the monument, welcomed visitors and collected artifacts associated with the president. On November 7, 1876, a group of counterfeiters attempted to steal Lincoln’s body to hold it for ransom. The Secret Service had learned of the plot, and Power assisted the authorities in preventing it. The attempt led to renewed precautions over the placement of the coffin, and in 1880 the Lincoln Guard of Honor was formed to protect the remains. Power became its secretary. He eventually published his own account of the attempted theft.
The custodians of the Lincoln family had been cabinetmakers, undertakers, railway employees, cemetery officials, Secret Service agents, trustees and members of a monument association. Their work continued well beyond the original funerals, and the president’s final interment in a reinforced chamber did not occur until 1901. By then John Carroll Power was himself buried in Oak Ridge. On his headstone, alongside the dates of his own life, an inscription records that he was on duty the night of November 7, 1876, when men attempted to steal the body of Abraham Lincoln. He is remembered in stone for the night he kept watch over the dead.