Unnameable Media

The Red Feather and the Shadow Heir

Part 13 of 15 in Exiled Courts and Private Empires

In 1751, a Saxon nobleman named Karl Gotthelf von Hund began building a Masonic order whose authority depended upon a man he would not identify. Hund said that in Paris in 1743 he had been received into a surviving Order of the Temple by the Knight of the Red Feather. The story associated his reception with the exiled Stuarts, and Charles Edward Stuart came to occupy the place of the unnamed superior. Behind that superior stood others, equally concealed. Hund’s system became the Rite of Strict Observance, and the obedience in its name was obedience to an authority whose credentials the ordinary member could not examine.

My intention here is to follow the possibility that an older dynastic practice found an American setting among the Bonapartes. A displaced house could lose its government while retaining relatives, property, dependants, correspondents, and men willing to undertake its business. By commission I mean the responsibility entrusted to such people, which might survive a change of sovereign or the disappearance of a throne. The Napoleonic Confederation of 1817 provides a concrete instance of the kind of organization at issue: its proposals describe commissioners, an executive committee, concealed recruitment, and a projected restoration in Mexico. They establish a historical undertaking around which the larger argument can be built. A continuous mandate from the Stuarts to Baltimore remains a hypothesis, to be tested against the family’s actual work. The American setting eventually reached across the Pacific. Spain’s defeat in 1898 placed the Philippines under an American claim of sovereignty, bringing the republic into the Asian commercial world that Spanish and Dutch imperial institutions had spent centuries helping to organize.

Charles Edward Stuart, 1739. Louis Gabriel Blanchet, Royal Collection.

The Stuart association with chivalric Freemasonry preceded Hund. Andrew Michael Ramsay briefly tutored Charles Edward in Rome in 1724, and his Masonic oration of 1736 supplied an influential account of the fraternity’s origins among crusaders. Men meeting in lodges were offered a genealogy reaching into Christian knighthood. The language of a lost inheritance, preserved among sworn companions, had an obvious attraction in the company of a dispossessed royal house. It could dignify loyalty after a military defeat and make an obligation to another man appear part of a much older duty. Strict Observance also concerned itself with material arrangements. An economic plan contemplated pooling the brothers’ resources. Read beside the system’s obligations, that proposal suggests an association in which capital, assistance, and allegiance belonged together. The extended household is a useful comparison: protection carried expectations, help created obligations, and introductions opened opportunities unavailable to an isolated man. A rite could give those relationships a hierarchy and rules for recognizing another member. Its ceremonies could teach a man where he stood before he was entrusted with consequential business. Secrecy, in that setting, could concern the identity of a patron, the purpose of an assignment, or simply the extent of an associate’s knowledge.

The concealed authority was disputed within Masonry itself. At Wilhelmsbad in 1782, delegates rejected the proposition that Freemasons were the successors of the medieval Templars. The problem was jurisdiction: a man might sincerely believe himself bound to a superior whom other brethren regarded as imaginary. The abandonment of Hund’s claim leaves a historical question about the people who had organized around it, their subsequent associations, and the obligations they continued to recognize.

In France, Fabré-Palaprat’s revival of the Order of the Temple in 1804 advanced a different succession. The Larmenius Charter purported to transmit authority from the medieval order; its list included Cossé-Brissac under 1776 and reached the modern revival. Whatever the charter’s antiquity, the nineteenth-century association left officers, publications, and administrative acts. James Burnes’s 1840 history reproduced a decree issued in May 1838 by Sir Sidney Smith as regent. Smith had helped defeat Napoleon at Acre in 1799. A chivalric association could thus bring a celebrated opponent of the emperor into a tradition cultivated during the imperial age, crossing a boundary that the history of national wars tends to preserve.

Tim Hogan’s modern account of the Templar tradition offers an intimate explanation for a Stuart-Bonaparte succession. In an interview, he described Napoleon as an illegitimate grandson of Charles Edward Stuart and identified Fabré-Palaprat as his physician. Neither the pedigree nor that medical appointment is established by the documentary evidence assembled here. Within Hogan’s account, the descent makes Napoleon the recipient of a Stuart inheritance alongside the French Templar succession. It gives the family’s later history a dynastic meaning, but the attribution matters: this is a tradition through which to read the records, rather than a pedigree those records have already confirmed.

An identifiable relationship with the imperial court appears in George Sherburn’s study of Roehenstart. Sherburn identifies Ferdinand de Rohan-Guémené as the father of the children of Charlotte Stuart, Charles Edward’s daughter. Ferdinand became grand almoner to Napoleon’s successive empresses. In February 1810 he wrote seeking the emperor’s favour; two days later Napoleon ordered a payment of 12,000 francs. Here the connection can be followed through an office, a letter, and money. A man belonging, in Sherburn’s reconstruction, to the intimate history of the Stuart descendants entered the service of the imperial household.

The institutions themselves had Atlantic histories. The French Supreme Council traces the movements of Alexandre de Grasse-Tilly, a soldier and Scottish Rite organizer, from Charleston to Saint-Domingue, where he served under Napoleon’s brother-in-law Leclerc, and back through Charleston to France in 1804. He then helped establish the Supreme Council in Paris. That movement joins American and Caribbean Masonic organization to the machinery developing under the First Empire. It gives the relationship between the two shores an institutional history as well as a family one: men displaced by colonial war carried offices and degrees with them, and reorganized after reaching another country.

The Bonapartes’ use of Masonic office is visible at the level of the family. Joseph became grand master of the Grand Orient of France, Louis held a senior position, and Jérôme headed the Grand Orient of Westphalia. Cambacérès occupied a major administrative role in imperial Masonry. Although Napoleon’s own initiation remains disputed, his relatives and senior servants exercised authority within the fraternity. The court could extend patronage through institutions whose relationships crossed borders and whose members already understood gradations of responsibility and obedience. After Waterloo, Joseph crossed the Atlantic and eventually established himself at Point Breeze near Bordentown, New Jersey. He arrived as a wealthy exile who had been king of Naples and then Spain. Former imperial officers considering their future could see in his presence a potential centre of patronage. America offered shelter and access to ports, western settlements, and the unsettled borders of Spanish America. Retirement, colonization, and restoration could occupy the same circle without every participant preferring the same outcome. An agricultural undertaking might attract men seeking a livelihood alongside others still searching for a political opportunity.

Point Breeze, Joseph Bonaparte’s New Jersey estate, 1817–20. Attributed to Charles B. Lawrence, Art Institute of Chicago.

Papers addressed to Joseph in 1817 under his title of Count de Survilliers came into the hands of the French minister in Washington, Hyde de Neuville. They were associated with Joseph Lakanal, the former Convention member and regicide who had taken refuge in America and settled in Kentucky near the French-speaking settlement of Vevay, Indiana, across the Ohio. A projected restoration was being discussed from the American interior, along the river routes leading toward the Gulf.

The plan reproduced by Jesse S. Reeves in The Napoleonic Exiles in America proposed expanding the Confederation to 900 armed members. It would designate 150 commissioners for recruitment across states and territories including Missouri, Illinois, Michigan, Tennessee, Kentucky, and Ohio, together with the District of Columbia. Each would recruit up to five people through personal connections, using benefits and anticipated rewards while withholding the ultimate objective. Commissioners would report daily in cipher to an executive committee. A separate agent would seek two field guns through Louisville, Natchez, and, if necessary, New Orleans. Joseph was asked for 65,000 francs toward the enterprise. The stated ambition was a dynastic restoration in Mexico. These were proposals submitted for his support, and Reeves did not establish that Joseph approved or financed the organization. The projected numbers cannot be treated as a verified force in the field. A companion petition addressed Joseph as king of Spain and the Indies and asked him to exercise sovereignty by granting commissions, distinctions, and titles; Lakanal sought a Spanish honour to enhance his standing. The projected Mexican venture therefore drew upon a claim left by Joseph’s Spanish reign, with the ex-king asked to authorize agents acting in its name. A cipher vocabulary allowed correspondence to be headed Oratio, giving it the appearance of religious material. Recognition and concealment were parts of the same design. Copies of Lakanal’s 1817 letters to Joseph remain catalogued at the British Library among diplomatic correspondence concerning the ex-king’s supposed designs against Spanish America.

Confederation names the association; commission describes the responsibility entrusted to an agent. The practical questions are those of a household extending its business beyond the reach of its head: who is trusted with money, who can make an introduction, who can recruit, and who needs to know the purpose. In the model proposed here, a man acquires responsibility through successive assignments without every stage being announced as a degree. Masonic advancement offers a comparison with that process, although a formal Masonic affiliation for the Confederation has not been demonstrated. The point of comparison is the management of trust. A person can belong to an undertaking before being told everything its organizers intend.

The Indies in Joseph’s Spanish title carried a geography larger than the Caribbean and Mexico. The Manila galleon trade, conventionally dated from 1565 to 1815, had linked the Philippines to Acapulco, exchanging American silver for Chinese silk and porcelain, ivory, spices, and other Asian goods. Cargo could cross Mexico for shipment to Spain, while much of it remained in the Americas. Manila belonged to an imperial economy that joined Asian producers and merchants to American mines and European consumers. The Mexican setting of the 1817 restoration proposal therefore occupied an old connection between the Atlantic and Pacific worlds. The proposal’s immediate objective was a throne in Mexico; the Spanish inheritance invoked by its petitioners had been built across both oceans.

The Dutch developed a different concentration of power within that same Asian trading world. Founded in 1602, the Dutch East India Company, or VOC, possessed a monopoly over Dutch commerce east of the Cape of Good Hope, maintained armed forces, and could negotiate treaties and administer territory. Batavia became its Asian headquarters in 1619. Pepper, nutmeg, and mace belonged to a much broader business in textiles, coffee, tea, timber, and porcelain. Its warehouses and shipping routes depended upon political privileges enforced by violence. American acquisition of the Philippines would eventually place Washington beside the Dutch colonial domain as a regional power, with an island base from which to pursue commerce and protect shipping. That later position gives the Spanish succession an Asian dimension extending well beyond a change of flags over Manila.

The Baltimore branch began with a different dispute over authority. On Christmas Eve 1803, Jérôme Bonaparte married Elizabeth Patterson in a ceremony performed by Bishop John Carroll. Napoleon opposed the match, sought its dissolution, and refused to let Elizabeth establish herself beside her husband in France. Pius VII would not grant the annulment Napoleon wanted. The French state nevertheless rejected the marriage, and Jérôme subsequently married Catherine of Württemberg and became king of Westphalia. Elizabeth’s son, Jérôme Napoléon, known as Bo, grew up with the Pattersons in Baltimore. His existence preserved a family relationship the emperor’s marriage policy had tried to subordinate to a European alliance.

Elizabeth Patterson Bonaparte, 1817. François Joseph Kinson, Maryland Center for History and Culture.

Elizabeth’s family brought substantial resources to the relationship. William Patterson made his fortune in commerce and real estate, became the first president of the Bank of Maryland, helped organize the Merchants’ Exchange, and was among the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad’s incorporators and first directors in 1827. His account books and autobiographical material describe a career extending through Philadelphia, the West Indies, and Baltimore. The American Bonapartes had married into an Atlantic merchant family with Caribbean experience long before Napoleon III’s Mexican intervention. The B&O directorship located that family within the construction of Baltimore’s access to the interior, giving the dynastic story a setting among the men financing and organizing American expansion. Bo continued corresponding with European relatives, including Joseph and Louis-Napoléon. Health, marriages, invitations, and family news maintained relationships across the Atlantic. Confidential government business could move along a channel that family life had helped keep open.

Jérôme Napoléon “Bo” Bonaparte, about 1850. Maryland Center for History and Culture.

Napoleon III’s parentage introduced another question of recognition. He was publicly the son of Louis Bonaparte and Hortense de Beauharnais, but rumours supplied alternative fathers, especially the Dutch admiral Verhuel. The name itself became a political taunt. Within Hogan’s proposed Stuart genealogy, the doubt would acquire an additional significance, since the emperor’s place in the asserted bloodline would depend upon Louis’s biological paternity. Bo’s uncontested descent from Jérôme would have a different standing in that account, alongside Jérôme’s European children and other Bonaparte branches. Descent, membership in the imperial family, and entitlement to succeed were distinct forms of standing, subject to different kinds of recognition.

Napoleon III, about 1860. Mayer & Pierson, George Eastman Museum.

Bo experienced those distinctions directly. Jean-Claude Lachnitt’s account of Bonaparte names and titles records that a decree of 30 August 1854 restored his French status and recognized him as legitimate under the Bonaparte name, without making him a prince. After protests from Prince Napoléon and Princess Mathilde, a family council in 1856 declared him illegitimate while leaving him the name. He refused an offered dukedom of Sartène. Recognition could be extended and restricted while kinship continued. The pope’s refusal to annul his parents’ marriage supplied a competing basis for legitimacy, though it did not automatically confer rights under the empire’s succession rules. The younger generation was already entering imperial service. Bo’s elder son, Jérôme Napoléon II, graduated from West Point in 1852, resigned from the United States Army in August 1854, and entered the French army, serving in the Crimea. An American home, contested European rank, and employment under the emperor could coexist within one household. In considering a commission, those working relationships deserve as much attention as the decree. The son held an actual military appointment during the years in which the father’s position was being reconsidered.

At Windsor on 18 April 1855, Victoria invested Napoleon III with the Order of the Garter. A special statute dispensed with existing rules in consideration of the friendship and alliance between the sovereigns. Albert and the Duke of Cambridge conducted the emperor into the chapter, and Victoria bestowed the insignia. While Bo’s standing was being negotiated within the Bonaparte family, the reigning emperor was receiving formal recognition from another royal house. On the Stuart reading proposed here, the ceremony acquires a further meaning as an encounter between inheritances separated by revolution and religion. The official account gives the Anglo-French alliance as its reason; it supplies no concealed Stuart instruction.

The Garter investiture of 18 April 1855, depicted by Edward Matthew Ward. Royal Collection.

The British monarchy already held material parts of the Stuart inheritance. George III supported Henry Benedict Stuart with a pension after his displacement during the French Revolutionary period; Stuart jewels and papers subsequently entered royal custody, and the Prince Regent acquired the exiled court’s archive. Patronage, custody of records, and preservation of regalia gave substance to a reconciliation between former rivals. Victoria herself descended from the Stuarts through the Hanoverian line. These relationships give the Windsor interpretation a historical setting, even though its strongest genealogical conclusion still depends upon the disputed Bonaparte descent. The empress beside Napoleon III brought an identifiable connection to Joseph’s Spanish reign. Her father, Cipriano, had served Joseph as a colonel, lost an eye at Seville, and participated in the defence of Paris in 1814. Her mother’s Kirkpatrick family supplied a Scottish connection, but the father’s service is the more direct political relationship. Napoleon III’s marriage joined him to a household with a history of loyalty to the earlier Bonaparte experiment in Spain. Spanish affairs belonged within the dynasty’s remembered experience as well as its foreign policy.

Lucien Murat moved between the American household world and French Masonic government. The son of Joachim Murat and Napoleon’s sister Caroline, he lived with his family in Bordentown before returning to France in 1848. In January 1852 he became grand master of the Grand Orient. His support for the pope’s temporal power later antagonized brethren, and the struggle over his succession ended with Napoleon III appointing Marshal Magnan in January 1862. Magnan had not been a Mason. The emperor intervened directly, and other Masons resisted attempts to extend the new grand master’s jurisdiction. Those disputes show the fraternity as a place where dynastic power was exercised and contested. Even a member of the imperial family had to contend with loyalties and convictions that his title could not command.

On 30 October 1854, President Franklin Pierce asked Bo to come to Washington and translate a paper. The Maryland Center for History and Culture’s catalogue provisionally identifies it with an October Note Confidentielle carried by Bo from the French government to the American president. Its description names French difficulties involving Patrice Dillon, Pierre Soulé, Romulus M. Saunders, Secretary of State Marcy, the proposed American purchase of Cuba, and American relations with Russia. The message’s full argument remains distinct from this inventory description, but Bo’s role as a carrier of confidential French business concerning Cuba is recorded. That was the autumn of the Ostend Manifesto, in which Soulé and his fellow American ministers advocated acquiring Cuba and contemplated force if Spain refused to sell. Pierce had appointed Soulé minister to Spain in 1853. Bo’s message belonged to an immediate crisis over expansion, slavery, and relations with European powers. Soulé’s other activities connect that diplomatic setting to the secret societies organizing around the island.

Soulé had served as president when the older Order of the Lone Star reorganized in the New Orleans area in 1851. The order sought Cuba, recruited armed volunteers, and developed a network extending into Texas. John A. Quitman, an organizer of Cuban filibustering and a former grand master of the Mississippi Masons, helped reorganize it. By April 1856, according to the Texas State Historical Association, the Lone Star had been mostly absorbed by or merged with the Knights of the Golden Circle (KGC). Here the connection runs through identifiable people and an organizational succession. The confidential French message concerning Soulé must still be read to determine what Bo’s involvement meant; carrying a message about an enterprise could place him in its diplomatic opposition as readily as among its supporters.

Pierre Soulé. Daguerreotype by Mathew Brady, Library of Congress.

The Knights of the Golden Circle placed Havana at the centre of a projected slaveholding empire encompassing the southern United States, the West Indies, Mexico, and parts of Central America. Sugar, tobacco, cotton, and the protection of slavery supplied its rationale. Although the organization dated its founding to 1854, its major organizing drive came in 1859–60. Military, commercial and financial, and political divisions assigned different functions to different groups, accompanied by signs, passwords, and ritual. Quitman’s career gives this setting an individual connection to senior Masonic office. The KGC’s own structure shows how fraternal forms could be put to the work of recruitment, finance, and territorial expansion, without establishing control by a Masonic governing body.

Napoleon III described a competing imperial calculation in his letter to General Forey of 3 July 1862. He warned against the United States taking possession of the Gulf and dominating the West Indies and South America. A French-supported government in Mexico would strengthen what he called the Latin race, protect French and Spanish Caribbean colonies, and serve French commerce and industry. The resulting project placed the Habsburg Maximilian on a Mexican throne. Joseph’s old Spanish title, the Confederation’s projected Mexican restoration, and Napoleon III’s later intervention all concerned the distribution of power in Spanish America. Their objectives and intended sovereigns varied. Cuba could be an object to annex, a Spanish possession to protect, or a strategic position whose future affected the whole Gulf. George Bickley himself described a conflict between the projects. David C. Keehn recounts that, while imprisoned in 1865, the KGC leader portrayed Napoleon III’s establishment of monarchy in Mexico as a frustration of the Knights’ purposes. The statement was part of Bickley’s defence of his record and has to be read accordingly. Even so, it places rivalry within the story. Men pursuing power in the same region could seek one another’s assistance and later find their projects incompatible. Their common geography makes the connection worth investigating; its political character has to emerge from their dealings.

Maximilian of Mexico, about 1864. J. Malvich, Trieste; Library of Congress.

Bo became the Maryland Club’s first president when it formed in 1857. Its members brought business and professional relationships into a setting where they could dine, exchange news, and introduce acquaintances outside their offices. In 1861, when much of the membership sympathized with the Confederacy, Bo resigned with other Unionists. Johns Hopkins remained and assumed a larger share of the club’s financial burden. The club’s own history preserves the division. A social institution associated with the Bonaparte household had become a place from which its founding president chose to withdraw. Union authorities subsequently closed the clubhouse, and Lew Wallace used it to shelter formerly enslaved people. Bo’s choice complicates a simple identification of his branch with Confederate expansion. His elder son served in the French army while he supported the Union at home. Those positions suggest room for a family to maintain relationships across national allegiances and make choices suited to different circumstances. They also make an independent American family interest a more substantial question than obedience to whatever Napoleon III preferred. The Baltimore branch had a position to preserve in the country where it lived.

Bo died in June 1870. The defeat at Sedan brought down Napoleon III’s empire in September. The American family survived with property, education, correspondence, and access to public life. Jérôme II’s military career had taken him into imperial service; his younger brother would enter the government of a republic. The loss of the European throne did not remove the American position from which the next generation could act.

Charles Joseph Bonaparte, born in Baltimore in 1851, made his career as an American lawyer and reformer. He helped found Maryland’s civil service reform association in 1881 and the Baltimore Reform League in 1885. His responsibilities included the Enoch Pratt Free Library and the Catholic University of America. The work concerned education, the conduct of elections, and the terms upon which men obtained public appointments. Through reform politics he developed his relationship with Theodore Roosevelt, who made him secretary of the Navy in 1905. These were the institutions through which the American Bonaparte acquired public authority, with an established family position behind him and a political career of his own.

Charles Joseph Bonaparte, 1903. J. E. Purdy, Library of Congress.

Spain’s Pacific inheritance had already transformed the scale of American power before Charles entered the cabinet. Under the Treaty of Paris of 10 December 1898, Spain relinquished its claim to Cuba and ceded Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines to the United States; the Philippine settlement included an American payment of $20 million. The treaty joined a Caribbean rearrangement to an acquisition on the western side of the Pacific. Spain yielded after military defeat, while Filipino revolutionaries continued to claim the independence for which they had fought. The Philippine-American War, beginning in 1899, made the coercion underlying American possession unmistakable. The succession involved an existing population, its own political aspirations, and a war over who could govern it. It also gave the United States ports and strategic positions within reach of the China trade and the commercial waters of Southeast Asia.

Roosevelt had helped prepare the Pacific operation while still assistant secretary of the Navy. His confidential dispatch to George Dewey on 25 February 1898 ordered the squadron to Hong Kong, instructed it to remain supplied with coal, and directed offensive operations in the Philippines if war with Spain came. The public crisis concerned Cuba, but the naval preparations already included Spain’s Asian position. By the time Roosevelt appointed Charles Bonaparte in July 1905, that operation had become a continuing obligation of government. The Navy secretary entered an administration responsible for maintaining an American presence across oceans, with colonial commitments and commercial interests that could require ships far from the mainland. Cuba and the Philippines belonged within the same field of responsibility.

Daniel Burnham’s Philippine work belonged to this government’s effort to establish itself in the territory acquired from Spain. In the winter of 1904–05, the Chicago architect visited the islands on a federal commission to plan Manila and a new summer capital at Baguio. The assignment brought the planner associated with the World’s Columbian Exposition into the everyday requirements of an overseas administration. William Howard Taft’s Philippine responsibilities and subsequent office as Roosevelt’s secretary of war supplied the administrative setting. Burnham’s work addressed how the colonial government would inhabit its possession: where its officials would work, how movement would be organized, and what kind of capital would announce their authority. His Philippine plans preceded the publication of the Plan of Chicago in 1909, placing Manila and Baguio within the same professional career as the American city whose growth he sought to order.

The Manila scheme placed a government centre within a proposed system of radiating arteries, a railway station, and a shore road. Baguio supplied an elevated seat for the administration during the hot season. Burnham and Edward Bennett’s Plan of Chicago later presented both Philippine projects alongside American examples and explained their national meaning: the two capitals would represent the “power and dignity of this nation.” The plans were proposals, carried out unevenly, but their purpose was explicit. Transportation, sanitation, recreation, and the grouping of public buildings would give the occupation an enduring physical form. Streets and civic spaces allowed an American administration to recast the setting in which Spanish authority had previously been displayed.

Burnham’s plan for Manila, 1905, reproduced in the Plan of Chicago (1909).

The commercial possibilities were described with comparable directness. The Bureau of Statistics’ The Commercial Philippines in 1906, published in January 1907, set American demand for tropical imports beside the islands’ potential production. It identified sugar, coffee, fibers, tobacco, and rubber; American rubber imports alone were valued at $40–50 million annually. Its rubber discussion compared plantation experiments in Java, the Straits Settlements, and Ceylon, and reported Philippine government nurseries distributing plants. Elsewhere it looked to Dutch methods in Java for restoring coffee production and noted American purchases of Sumatran tobacco. The older colonial trading region supplied both competitors and models for development under American rule.

Rubber was becoming one of the materials through which industrial growth changed the value of tropical territory. Hevea came from the Amazon region; Henry Wickham’s shipment of seeds to Kew in 1876 helped establish the stock from which Asian plantation cultivation developed. Singapore’s botanic gardens received plants in 1877, and Henry Nicholas Ridley subsequently promoted cultivation and methods of tapping. British Malaya and Ceylon, together with the Dutch East Indies, became centres of an industry serving expanding uses in tires, machinery, and manufactured goods. The relationship to the spice trade lay in the region’s continuing importance to overseas commerce and in the colonial institutions capable of directing land, labour, shipping, and investment toward a valuable crop. New demand could increase the importance of an old imperial position.

Carrying latex to a factory in Malaya. M. S. Nakajima; reproduced in Edith A. Browne’s Rubber (1920).

American official interest in Philippine rubber reached the Senate. On 27 February 1907 the secretary of war submitted information on the islands’ rubber-producing capacity in response to a Senate resolution. The inquiry concerned an opportunity whose scale still had to be established. Potential cultivation belonged beside the existing regional plantations, and the attraction was access to a material the industrial economy increasingly required. A related tropical product, gutta-percha, had already acquired a strategic use as insulation for submarine telegraph cables. The Atlantic cable of 1866 combined a gutta-percha-insulated copper core with protective layers that included manila yarn. Tropical forest products helped carry the communications by which distant governments, naval stations, and businesses coordinated their work. Control of a producing region could matter to the operation of the wider imperial system.

Roosevelt’s own programme connected colonial possession to the terms of commerce. In his annual message of December 1905 he urged lower duties on Philippine products, sought eventual free trade, and argued against shipping restrictions that would obstruct exchange between the islands and the United States. The same message addressed Hawaiian fortifications and the Panama Canal, whose construction the United States had taken over in 1904. A canal through the isthmus would shorten the sea connection between the American Atlantic coast and the Pacific. Taken together, those policies concerned the movement of goods and naval power through an oceanic system. The Caribbean, the crossing at Panama, and the Philippine position could be governed as parts of a national strategy extending well beyond the continental frontier.

The personal world behind that expansion also crossed older allegiances. At Mobile in October 1905, Roosevelt publicly recalled that one uncle had served under Raphael Semmes on the Confederate Alabama and another had arranged its construction. He then praised the Philippine governor, an ex-Confederate married to Semmes’s daughter, before turning to the benefits the Panama Canal would bring the Gulf. In a single address, family memory, Confederate naval service, Philippine administration, and the canal entered Roosevelt’s account of American national power. Such relationships supplied an actual social setting for the passage of older experience into a new imperial employment.

For Charles Bonaparte, the position was therefore larger than a return to his father’s Cuban business. His office belonged to an administration consolidating territory acquired from Spain, reorganizing its capitals, examining tropical production, and improving the means of movement between oceans. Burnham’s commission and Bonaparte’s cabinet appointment assigned different work within that undertaking. Their conjunction supplies a concrete American setting for the larger question posed here: how men formed within established families and professional circles received responsibility for governing an imperial inheritance. In the Philippines, responsibility concerned a population and a regional commercial position whose history reached back through Spain’s Pacific empire to the trading world of the Dutch East Indies.

Cuba returned to the family’s official business during his naval secretaryship. In September 1906, political upheaval on the island brought American warships and landing parties into the crisis. Sailors and Marines from Denver went ashore on 13 September; further vessels moved men and supplies through Cuban ports as the intervention developed into an American occupation. Charles held the civilian office overseeing the Navy involved in those operations. Andrew Jampoler’s account of his secretaryship places them within the Monroe Doctrine, Roosevelt’s corollary, and the Platt Amendment. The American Bonaparte was exercising an American authority over a region that French imperial policy had once sought to keep from American predominance. Letters to his wife Ellen, described in the catalogue of his papers, discussed the Cuban crisis, Taft’s mission, and ship movements alongside household matters. Correspondence with Elihu Root concerned Navy business. The letters bring official decisions back into the scale of family life: an officeholder wrote home about a crisis in a region that had occupied his father’s confidential diplomacy. His judgments can be examined there without assuming that he had inherited a fixed Cuban policy.

USS Denver at Havana, before the First World War. Naval History and Heritage Command, NH 79727.

A family agenda would have had to accommodate considerable change. Joseph’s projected restoration concerned a Bonaparte sovereign in Mexico; Napoleon III’s intervention installed a Habsburg; Charles served a republic extending its regional authority after Spain’s defeat. An inherited network could survive by accepting new employers, objectives, and forms of office. The American branch is interesting because its position endured. Its members could enter French service, carry business between governments, and obtain an American cabinet appointment while remaining part of the same transatlantic household. Continuity of access could outlast agreement over the use to which it should be put. The Philippines enlarge the scale of that survival. The American branch had entered the cabinet of a government exercising authority over former Spanish possessions in both the Caribbean and the Pacific, beside the established colonial powers of Southeast Asia. Its European name now belonged to the officials administering the reach of an American republic.

Charles became attorney general in December 1906. After Congress restricted the Justice Department’s use of Treasury Secret Service personnel in 1908, he organized an investigative force within his own department. His order of 26 July is the date the FBI recognizes as its founding. Under his successor, George Wickersham, the force acquired the name Bureau of Investigation in March 1909; Federal Bureau of Investigation followed in 1935. A member of the American Bonaparte household had helped build a permanent investigative capacity inside the federal government. The institutional result is clear. It leaves open the larger question of what habits of trust, appointment, and administration he brought to that work.

Theodore Roosevelt and his cabinet, 1906. Harris & Ewing, National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution.

The commission I am proposing concerns that capacity to entrust responsibilities and preserve influence through changes of regime. Its historical points of reference are particular acts: the proposed commissions and honours of 1817, recognition and military employment in the 1850s, confidential diplomacy, and later cabinet responsibility. Stuart and Templar traditions provide a language for interpreting those acts; the records establish particular relationships rather than an unbroken succession of secret appointments. What emerges is a substantial history of the American Bonapartes acting within the political world left by Spain’s empire, from a family position that survived the collapse of their own. Burnham’s Philippine assignment gives the comparison a material setting outside the Bonaparte household: a federal commission translated political authority into plans for capitals and transportation. The trade reports identify the production and exchange that officials hoped to develop around that authority. These are different forms of entrusted work through which imperial possession could become an operating system of government.

In 1854, Bo carried a confidential French message concerning Cuba to President Pierce. Fifty-two years later, his son was secretary of the Navy during an American intervention on the island. Between those transactions lay the Mexican empire, the Civil War, the fall of Napoleon III, and the defeat of Spain. The family remained established within the republic and present in the decisions that followed. That American position, and the responsibilities exercised from it, gives the proposed commission its historical setting. Beyond Cuba lay Manila and Baguio, Guam and the Panama crossing, and an Asian commercial region whose older Spanish and Dutch institutions had made tropical goods central to world trade. The republic acquired a place within that world through war and then set officials, planners, and commercial investigators to the work of securing it. The American Bonaparte occupied a cabinet office within that enlargement of power. The history of the family and the history of imperial succession meet there, where inherited access became responsibility for a government reaching across both oceans.

Leave a comment